GKMC vs Reasonable Doubt

[Illeye buckmatic]

EDIT:Ignore the poll The original comparison was gkmc vs MCHG. K. Dot was winning with over 90% of the votes. So everyone wanted reasonable doubt to replace MCHG So I changed the thread instead of making another Jay comparison thread because there's already too many So just ignore the poll and just pick between rd or gkmc
Now that Jay's album has finally sunk in,let's compare it to kendrick's
I knew everyone was gonna compare it to LIG,but I feel production wise and mainstream appeal,these two albums are more comparable.

So which album had better production? Subject matter? Which was better lyrically?

Yall know my answer to these questions already so I'll wait a lil bit before answering

 

[Canada Goose]

Kendricks album was MUCH better than Jay's album IMO.

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

Waiting on dem camel riders to come in and throw sand on this thread

 

[zerozero]

Kendrick by miles

 

[DanielAlfredsson]

Kendrick's album, and it's not even close brehs. I STILL bump Kendrick's album from start to finish. Meanwhile, after only a few weeks, I'm already skipping half of Hov's album.

 

[atlbound]

GKMC is a better listen musically and lyrically but Jays album is a classic (just like Bp3), sooo......

 

[Steve Piffler]

Waiting on dem camel riders to come in and throw sand on this thread

jay-z's album was better

Spoiler

 

[spliz]

lmao...

 

[The 2020 New Member]

both were amazing bodies of work but k-dot had that breakthrough. the production was solid and the lyrics/flow were very impressive. i would go to in depth with one post tho.

 

[Never Broke Again]

Kendrick let go a classic

Jay released a great album but he aint seein that

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

jay-z's album was better

Spoiler

 

[mikishere]

kendrick

 

[spliz]

no..they were not "both" amazing bodies of work...Kendrick's album was an amazing body of work and I dont even think that's the best thing since sliced bread like everyone be tryna make it..but it is a tremendous effort tho...Jay's album is only ok for his standards...nothing amazing about it...and that's ok..not every listenable album that comes out has to be considered great..and I think that's where shyt gets fukked up these days...there's too much exaggeration...

 

[atlbound]

^^ nah, Jays album was definitely a classic. It wasnt really that good though

 

[GoldenGlove]

We'll be listening to GKMC 10 years from now and still be like

MCHG will get played for a few months and be forgotten.