You really couldn't have proven my point any better...
I said nothing about the experience of Detroit students or DeVos. My statement had to do with the nature of the debate as opposed to the debate itself, and you did exactly what I'm talking about. Public education is just another talking point for people who only care about winning the argument. Republicans condemn public school not because they care about kids or education, but because it serves their broader political and economic aims, and Democrats do the same with charter schools.
You say my comments are disingenuous because you assume I'm pushing some pro-Trump/pro-Republican narrative, which is ridiculous. I'm a public school teacher. DeVos and what she represents present a direct threat to my personal well being and how I provide for my family. If I were to approach this from a purely self-interested perspective then I would pick up the pitch fork and demonize all things Republican. But, she's just a symptom of a larger problem that I've seen play out my entire career, and the biggest losers are American students. They're pawns in a partisan con, which you are perpetuating with posts like this.
The simple fact is that public education has failed, particularly in urban districts, and charter schools have failed. Blind partisanship requires you to focus on only one side to win the argument...which is your real motivation. If the discussion on education was genuine, and not just another talking point to win the partisan argument, then we could get at the real problem that is plaguing American education. The discussion is not genuine, though, and you just proved it.