2010-2011 Cameron Newton vs. 2012-2013 Johnny Manziel

[Rigby.]

#2 vs. #2

Both coming off of transfers

Both had a connection with a Texas program

Both backed up national championship contenders @ QB for very short periods of time

Both came out of nowhere to beat Alabama in pretty GOAT games

Both had incidents at some time

Both have the most swag in the NFL

 

[Rigby.]

Both won a heisman and won a bowl game

 

[Rigby.]

....

 

[CarltonJunior]

Cam >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

 

[Millions]

manziel aint got shyt on the GAWD Killa tho aka the Lebron James of the NFL

Teddy gone be a better pro then johnny football

 

[distinguishedNOW]

Cam won a Nat'l title.

 

[Axum Ezana]

wow. this easy buddy.



should have did Wilson....at least he got a sb ring.

hard to make cam go against past nc and Heisman winners because he's the best out of all those lame ass nikkas easily

 

[Vancouver Grizzly Fan]

What?

Since when did we start comparing Denzel Washington to Jim Carrey. Cam is clearly better.

 

[Heelmatic]

Johnny my dude but at "they both won a bowl game"

Come on now

 

[Rigby.]

Johnny my dude but at "they both won a bowl game"

Come on now

I mean it's sort of uneven because Auburn had the better coach (chizik doesn't count), a far better defense, and a better everything lol

The only thing that's arguable is the two heismen winner

 

[El Bombi]

#2 vs. #2

1)Both coming off of transfers

Both had a connection with a Texas program

2)Both backed up national championship contenders @ QB for very short periods of time

3)Both came out of nowhere to beat Alabama in pretty GOAT games

Both had incidents at some time

Both have the most swag in the NFL

1) ?????? When did Manziel transferred to Texas A&M?


2) ?????? Who is the NC contender QB that Manziel back up?


3) Supa Killa was already the favorite to win the Heisman and Auburn was the favorite heading into that Alabama game.

 

[Rigby.]

Oregon, Darren Thomas, Auburn was ranked #23 preseason and pundits had Cameron as a receiver or tight end at the next level, so you're wrong on all accounts.

1) ?????? When did Manziel transferred to Texas A&M?


2) ?????? Who is the NC contender QB that Manziel back up?


3) Supa Killa was already the favorite to win the Heisman and Auburn was the favorite heading into that Alabama game.

 

[godkiller]

#2 vs. #2

Both coming off of transfers

Both had a connection with a Texas program

Both backed up national championship contenders @ QB for very short periods of time

Both came out of nowhere to beat Alabama in pretty GOAT games

Both had incidents at some time

Both have the most swag in the NFL

Manziel is the lesser prospect in my eyes. He goes through reads better and is smarter, but Newton leads in every other category. When Newton came out he had a stronger arm, better pocket presence and prototype size. He was also about as talented a runner as Manziel.

 

[GatorStaceyAdams]

Manziel is the lesser prospect in my eyes. He goes through reads better and is smarter, but Newton leads in every other category. When Newton came out he had a stronger arm, better pocket presence and prototype size. He was also about as talented a runner as Manziel.

#1 read) Scramble around carelessly
#2 read) Throw a jump ball up to my all-american WR
#3 read) Run around more for the hell of it
#4 read) Lets try that jump ball up to my all-american WR again

Also, Cam was a faster and better runner than Manziel coming out while being close to 40 pounds heavier

 

[Brady-Carter]

Oregon, Darren Thomas, Auburn was ranked #23 preseason and pundits had Cameron as a receiver or tight end at the next level, so you're wrong on all accounts.

Jesus christ this is so wrong. Manziel committed to Oregon then de-comitted. Manziel redshirted at TAMU behind Ryan Tannehill.