One of the Football Focus dudes hit me and asked what about it I disagreed with
1. This is based on rosters remaining the same for half a decade and no roster upgrades, drafts, career ending injuries for his team or teams he'll face, etc, etc....
2. Carson fukkin Palmer was rated #1
3. This is a historical reach considering out of the 13 you chose to list, only 3 have won titles
Predicted And Actual Performance For
No. 1 Overall Picks
PLAYER PREDICTED DYAR IN YRS 3-5 ACTUAL DYAR IN YRS 3-5
Carson Palmer 2,266 2,268
Peyton Manning 1,463 3,922
Matthew Staffod 1,125 3,021
Andrew Luck 1,076 879 (Yr 3 only)
Eli Manning 892 1,179
Cam Newton 781 316 (Yrs 3-4 only)
Alex Smith 771 -763
Sam Bradford 617 692
JaMarcus Russell 535 -834
Tim Couch 428 -366
Jameis Winston 378 *
David Carr 365 -215
Michael Vick -446 -518
Note: Passing DYAR only, does not incorporate rushing value.
4. None of this shyt can be held against someone who has YET TO TAKE A fukkIN SNAP
It was plenty more but dude ended up blocking me