She got better as a singer after her debut. In Love and War got some solid vocal work by her. And leagues beyond Ashanti IDK how she even made it.Like somebody else said, she would’ve sounded better had she actually been singing the entire duration of her career. You can tell she went on a lengthy hiatus. She was never some very strong singer vocally, she was in that light Ciara/Ashanti category, but to say she was horrific is pretty silly.