List some players where you think it's questionable if they make the HOF.
I say yes for Geno Atkins.
I say yes for Geno Atkins.
Are They a Hall of Famer? NFL Edition
- Thread starter BucciMane
- Start date
Ghostface Trillah
God-level poster
Probably should post numbers compared to other Hall of Fame players or it's going to be a lot of emotional arguments vs reasonable ones.
I'll post some shortly, but I feel like NFL discussions here as much better and more civil than NBA ones.
.Even when I tell @O.iatlhawksfan and @ReturnOfJudah that I think Burrow is overrated, we can still have a good discussion.
.
Lucky_Lefty
Dreams Are Colder Than Death...
I'm sitting this one out. Feels like the beginning of the shyt storm I started in the group chat the other day when I said Dez wasn't even a T10 receiver in the '10s and was just a TD merchant/specialist.
How is anyone trying to argue he’s even close to the hof?
.
What about Adam Vinatieri?
Lucky_Lefty
Dreams Are Colder Than Death...
Nah, they were arguing against my notion that he wasn't one of the ten best of the last decade.
Last edited:
JesusFOREVER
Superstar
I’m sure you have a reasonable argument to support this but i need to hear it cause this just sounds like pure hate
Ghostface Trillah
God-level poster
I'll post some shortly, but I feel like NFL discussions here as much better and more civil than NBA ones.
Even when I tell @O.iatlhawksfan and @ReturnOfJudah that I think Burrow is overrated, we can still have a good discussion.
Because NBA discourse is rooted in deep hate or passionate stanning.
For instance if I say "That one poster who stans LeBron no matter what" or "That one poster who hates LeBron no matter what" you don't even know who I'm talking about because you can name 4-5 posters on for both statements.
And Burrow isn't overrated. He's this generations Dan Marino. Incredibly talented but will waste away because his front office and ownership are idiots. 20 years from now there will threads that Joe Burrow should have a ring but he never had help and someone will be in there arguing that he had Chase and Higgins and then name Hendrickson and some fringe defensive star trying to justify that Burrow had help.
IsThatBrothaMouzone?
Veteran
Darren Woodson
I agree with your first part. I'll keep Burrow out of here, although he's living off one playoff run where the Benglals biggest plays were screens and a play that should have been OPI on Higgins. Burrow comes up short in big moments.
.Not sure what you're saying. I'm not saying he should be, but I'll say he is ten times more worthy than Devin Hester who somehow got in. That is a disgrace for the Pro Football HOF.
Ghostface Trillah
God-level poster
The Bengals were a blind referee away from going back to the Superbowl though and the then the front office decided get defensive players off of the clearance rack and not lock in the offensive weapons. Instead of capitalizing on chemistry. The Bengals start slow every season because Burrow has to get chemistry with new offensive players every year except for Higgins and Chase