as a ny giants fan...eli gotta go :camby:

[The Frozen One]

we got great receivers but an aging QB that throws ducks...defense looking deadly, the recipe is there for superbowl run, but the offense is worst 10 in the league.

i love eli, he beat brady and bellichek twice in the superbowl but at this stage in his career, he gotta go.

question is, who can replace him?

 

[Adebisi_Said]

question is, who can replace him?

Answer: NOBODY

 

[Scottie Drippin]

We have a terrible o line and no running game. How about we demand the team fix that before trying to replace a 2x superbowl winning, franchise QB

 

[Kinguno]

Last season he cost us many a game but somehow OBJ got all the blame

Eli going to be there until he gets Bledsoed

 

[feelosofer]

What are you going to do, start Geno Smith? I mean if the coaching staff really tries to develop him he can maybe compete for a starting job in maybe 2 or 3 years but even then theres Davis Webb. Seriously for all of Eli's flaws he gives you the best chance to win especially in the postseason.

 

[Box Factory]

This is disrespectful

 

[duckbutta]

What are you going to do, start Geno Smith? I mean if the coaching staff really tries to develop him he can maybe compete for a starting job in maybe 2 or 3 years but even then theres Davis Webb. Seriously for all of Eli's flaws he gives you the best chance to win especially in the postseason.

 

[filial_piety]

I think he has 1 or maybe 2 seasons left before the NYGs let him bow out.

problem is that they haven't mentored anyone in over 10 years because he hasnt missed a game since 05'

Gino SMith is the back up...honestly that guy isn't good enough to even be in the league.

And once Eli bounces, the giants are gonna go through a QB shuffle like the Jets did for a few years

 

[Thegospel]

We'll start his ending week 1. We got you Brodie

Eli gotta fall off at some point and the signs are already there. That 3-13 year when he officially is done

 

[Weaver31]

He got 2 rings and he the only one who beat Brady (thus far )...that's good job security

His game gotta really decline to Blake Bortles status. He never gets injured so that prevents him from getting Bledsoe'd.

 

[woof]

Eli isn't in his prime peak anymore, but OP deserves to spend four quarters behind Ereck Flowers in a regular season game for this.

The offense, now that they upgraded their TEs to NFL quality and have someone better than a guy who can't even make the Bears pre-season second-teamers at WR2, will be back in the top half of the league so long as the OL tones down their fukkery a little (and McAdoo remembers how to call plays).

 

[Rottweiler]

Eli is past his prime but he's still a good QB. The biggest problems with the Giants O have been OL and RBs. Try to actually watch games before posting dumb shyt OP.

 

[manning2nicks]

Smh he was the best player in the greenbay playoff game last year. Eli Manning is my last concern About this team. He's got a good two years left.

 

[I.V.]

Nah, this dude is banned from the fan base.

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

Eli's always been streaky.


He'll probably get hot at some point.