Battle of the Classics #1 - Boyz N The Hood vs Menace II Society... which film was better?

[Kool]

These Battle of the Classics threads are about those classic movies and albums that people go back and forth about which one was better. We're going to settle this shyt today! First up are these two classic flicks....

vs


Both of these movies are classics but which film was better? Place your vote!

Boyz N The Hood



Menace II Society

 

[TheDarkCloud]

Idk breh. Ricky’s death fukked me up. But Harold’s death in Menace still has me feelin a way, too.



Why homie couldn’t just give up the whip?

 

[@OffHalsted]

BNTH was more authentic, especially when Ricky got popped Cube & Trey sitting on porch scene nikka disappeared afterwards ....

Menace was a hood story on roids

 

[PuffTheMagicDragon]

I can watch Menace all day.

Boyz doesn't have the same feeling after the first watch.

 

[Clay Puppington]

Menace cause of the savagery. O-Dog making fun of Cain after he got shot, "you done fukked up right", O-Dog laughin bout robbin the store, smoking the crackhead, and my fav part - MC Eiht "Aye homie you need some help??"

 

[Kool]

Boyz N the Hood was the better film.

 

[Kool]

BNTH was more authentic, especially when Ricky got popped Cube & Trey sitting on porch scene nikka disappeared afterwards ....

Menace was a hood story on roids

This... Menace was trying too hard. The O-dog character was almost cartoonish. Boyz n the Hood was a better made movie IMO.

 

[skeetsinternal]

I'm a Paid in Full and Shottas dude but I will go with Menace

 

[Noriega]

Eh I liked the storyline in BNDH better

Menace II Society was full of fukkery

 

[Milk N Cookies]

Idk breh. Ricky’s death fukked me up. But Harold’s death in Menace still has me feelin a way, too.



Why homie couldn’t just give up the whip?

I’ve been wanting to make a thread for a while now about Rick’s death. Do y’all think he would have live much longer had he not gotten shot in the alley? Mind you he wasn’t that smart, he had his athletic talents, and he also wasn’t street smart either. He cause me a fight that night when he was talking shyt to the dude with the Bulls skullcap and said ‘I don’t know Figga!!’ (Yes he said FIGGA not n*gga) And who stepped in and stopped things from going off? His brother . Even tho they came back later shooting... and let’s not forget when they were kids & Rick got his ball taken... dough boy went and got it back. He got roughed up... but he got rick his ball back.


That said, do y’all think Rick would have gotten killed still? When he came home from school to visit his family... do y’all think some hating ass nikkas would have taken him out?

 

[richaveli83]

Menace to Society

 

[ndthentherewasx]

Boyz and it isn't even close

 

[richaveli83]

I’ve been wanting to make a thread for a while now about Rick’s death. Do y’all think he would have live much longer had he not gotten shot in the alley? Mind you he wasn’t that smart, he had his athletic talents, and he also wasn’t street smart either. He cause me a fight that night when he was talking shyt to the dude with the Bulls skullcap and said ‘I don’t know Figga!!’ (Yes he said FIGGA not n*gga) And who stepped in and stopped things from going off? His brother . Even tho they came back later shooting... and let’s not forget when they were kids & Rick got his ball taken... dough boy went and got it back. He got roughed up... but he got rick his ball back.


That said, do y’all think Rick would have gotten killed still? When he came home from school to visit his family... do y’all think some hating ass nikkas would have taken him out?

He would have made it. He would have hooked up with some PAWG in college who wouldn't have given him the time of day if wasn't playing for the school.

 

[(Lean Ambrose)]

Dead ass and I don't care how Sawft I sound, but I get choked up at the end of Boys N The Hood everytime...
On topic I refuse to pick one, the question is blasphemous...

 

[John Hull]

BNTH was more authentic, especially when Ricky got popped Cube & Trey sitting on porch scene nikka disappeared afterwards ....

Menace was a hood story on roids

Nah. Boyz N Da Hood was an afterschool special.