DD4's from Goldeneye - those silver jawns were my shyt in license to kill mode.
Lancer w/ Chainsaw from Gears of War - first time wielding that shyt and turning a locust into ground beef...
Default pistol from Halo 1 - That shyt...I'd probably grab that in a video game gun draft first.
M1 Garand from Call of Duty 2 - No explanation needed, just listen for the 'ping' sound at the end of a clip.

Sex would be better if when I bust inside of a jawn's mouth, I could hear that 'ping' sound.
Pump Action Shotty from Red Dead Redemption 2 - Almost nothing more satisfying than ending a nikka's chances of being in the sequel with this shyt.
211-V Plasma Cutter from Dead Space - Man listen...
M14 Rifle from Modern Warfare 1 - That was the grandchild of my love of the M1.
------------------------
EDIT: I feel like I blasphemed when I read
@Kamikaze Revy mentioning the
Master Sword, how could I forget. Dun dun dun duuuuuuuuuuuunn when you grab it out of the stone in a
Link to the Past.

