Do you agree with this football analyst's QB rankings? (explain why or why not)

[godkiller]

Football analyst Cian Fahey (Bleacher Report writer, Football Outsiders and former Rotoworld contributor) presents his 2015 QB Rankings. Do you agree with his rankings and logic (please explain why or why not):

 

[Steezy]

this won't end well

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

no

 

[FakeNews]

Why will Mariota's transition be better than that of Jameis?

 

[BlueHeffner]

Pretty accurate

 

[HearNoEvil]

Jameis got more weapons and already played in a pro style offense so there's no way Mariota adjusts easier

 

[Rigby.]

Anyone on this forum that says theyll take Brees or Ryan over Cam can see me in Temecula with my nikka Steve Nash

Nah seriously, there's some inconstency here

 

[King Crimson]

Why will Mariota's transition be better than that of Jameis?

Yeah, that shyt was puzzling as fukk. Jameis is far more pro-ready than Marcus.

 

[godkiller]

Yeah, that shyt was puzzling as fukk. Jameis is far more pro-ready than Marcus.

Why will Mariota's transition be better than that of Jameis?

Fahey will tell you Mariota will have an easier time transitioning because the latter can run the read option until he's ready to play pro style, but from Fahey's past writings, I can tell you he believes that Mariota is more accurate than Jameis and makes better decisions. He ranked Mariota as the #1 QB in his mock draft.

 

[BonafideDefacto]

fukk these dudes who keep anointing Luck. That's my Stanford fam but till he proves he's not a turnover mchine I don't want to see him in tier 2.

And did this nikka really put Brady in tier 4 after what he does with non elite wrs

 

[godkiller]

fukk these dudes who keep anointing Luck. That's my Stanford fam but till he proves he's not a turnover mchine I don't want to see him in tier 2.

And did this nikka really put Brady in tier 4 after what he does with non elite wrs

I think Fahey is projecting Luck as Tier 2 going forward and dropping Brady accordingly. But I disagree. Brady should be Tier 2.

 

[MF budz]

Tim Brady relies on strengths to cover weaknesses? Isn't that what every fukkin player does?!

 

[Bboystyle]

Lol the top ten is hilarious. Some how Brady gonna lose a step but Ben and Matt Ryan are gonna beast. Yea ok

 

[BaggerofTea]

Love his teddy ranking but thats about it

 

[Juggalo Fred]

Ryan Tranny-hill over Joe Flacco?


this list is wacko