That back surgery was what...3 years ago :yeahok:
And that surgery is nothing compared to the microfracture surgery that Amare had...which pretty much shortens your career if not outright end it...
How is this even a question. Dwight has been a more productive player than Amare for...well basically his entire career
Amare and Melo was worse but Dwight has more all star appearances than Amare...more all nba team selections than Amare...more DPOY awards than Amare...averages more rebounds for his career...blocks more shots for his career...has better career playoff highs than Amare...