"Futbol" Fans, Suspension For A Handball?

[BucciMane]

I understand for a tackle and other shyt during the game that it results in a suspension, but please explain how a red card for a handball is deserving of a suspension? I know it's an automatic one game for a red card, but for a hand ball it's the same?!

I won't even get started on what a gimmick and disgrace going to PK's are.....


It makes zero sense how a hand ball that is given a red card results in a one game suspension..

 

[SmoothOperator88]

I understand for a tackle and other shyt during the game that it results in a suspension, but please explain how a red card for a handball is deserving of a suspension? I know it's an automatic one game for a red card, but for a hand ball it's the same?!

I won't even get started on what a gimmick and disgrace going to PK's are.....


It makes zero sense how a hand ball that is given a red card results in a one game suspension..

/end thread

 

[BucciMane]

/end thread

Great response!.


It makes little sense how a hard slide tackle or dirty plays receives the same punishment as a handball. Yes, I know both can result in red cards, but its absurd that a handball can get you suspended, especially in the World Cup.

Suspend NFL players for pass interference...

Suspends NBA players for goaltending.....


Both of those prevent scoring opportunities just like a handball, but neither result in anything CLOSE to an ejection AND a one game suspension..


Makes no sense at all. At least give some better reasoning.

 

[Apprentice]

Great response!.


It makes little sense how a hard slide tackle or dirty plays receives the same punishment as a handball. Yes, I know both can result in red cards, but its absurd that a handball can get you suspended, especially in the World Cup.

Suspend NFL players for pass interference...

Suspends NBA players for goaltending.....


Both of those prevent scoring opportunities just like a handball, but neither result in anything CLOSE to an ejection AND a one game suspension..


Makes no sense at all. At least give some better reasoning.

nikka he responded that way cuz that isnt true lol

 

[concise]

All red cards mean you are out of the game you're playing and the next one. It is set up to be a deterrent.

 

[BucciMane]

nikka he responded that way cuz that isnt true lol

What's not true?

All red cards mean you are out of the game you're playing and the next one. It is set up to be a deterrent.

Yes, I understand that you are thrown out of the current game and suspended the following one, but do you honestly think that a handball should be a red card? It seems very extreme to be ejected AND suspended for a handball.

 

[JDH]

What's not true?



Yes, I understand that you are thrown out of the current game and suspended the following one, but do you honestly think that a handball should be a red card? It seems very extreme to be ejected AND suspended for a handball.

It doesnt have to be a red card. In most cases it is not. If you are referring to the Japan - Colombia game then he got a red beause he stopped a clear goal which would have went in if he hadn't stopped it

 

[concise]

What's not true?



Yes, I understand that you are thrown out of the current game and suspended the following one, but do you honestly think that a handball should be a red card? It seems very extreme to be ejected AND suspended for a handball.

No, yellow and red cards are set up not just for overly physical play but also to discourage things like excessive time wasting but also super negative tactics. Goals in this sport do not come as often as they do in basketball, so the punishment has to be harsher. And it is a red for handballs stopping goals. Other deliberate handballs are yellows.

 

[BucciMane]

It doesnt have to be a red card. In most cases it is not. If you are referring to the Japan - Colombia game then he got a red beause he stopped a clear goal which would have went in if he hadn't stopped it

I know the handball can be a yellow card. I'm saying that I know a hand ball that gets a red card results in ejection and suspension, which seems extremely excessive. Japan got a PK and a man up out of it, and Colombia gets a man down and a one game suspension. That's insane.

 

[3rdLetter]

That's the rule You use your hand or arm to stop an obvious goal scoring opportunity and you ain't the goalkeeper, you gotta go If a deliberate handball in the box was only a yellow, you'd see it happening much more often. It only seems excessive b/c dumbass did it 3 minutes into the game

 

[BucciMane]

That's the rule You use your hand or arm to stop an obvious goal scoring opportunity and you ain't the goalkeeper, you gotta go If a deliberate handball in the box was only a yellow, you'd see it happening much more often. It only seems excessive b/c dumbass did it 3 minutes into the game

I took Japan in my bracket, so I'm fine with him being bushed today.

I don't have an issue with the ejection, but with someone being suspended the following game. Yes, I know he received a red card and that the red card results in a suspension, but I think it's absurd that a red card for a hand-ball can result in an ejection AND a suspension. That's all I'm saying.

I know that it's supposed to be a deterrent, but it extreme.


Correct me if I'm wrong, but with a red card for a hand-ball in the box, the following happens:


Team that commits hand-ball: Loses one man for the rest of the match and has that player suspended for the next game.

Team that had the infraction committed against them: Gets a man up for the rest of the game (baring any other red cards) AND gets a PK.


Getting a PK and having the opponent receive a yellow card seems more than enough. But, not only do they get a PK in this situation, they play the rest of the game a man up, baring any other cards.....

 

[DStyles]

I took Japan in my bracket, so I'm fine with him being bushed today.

I don't have an issue with the ejection, but with someone being suspended the following game. Yes, I know he received a red card and that the red card results in a suspension, but I think it's absurd that a red card for a hand-ball can result in an ejection AND a suspension. That's all I'm saying.

I know that it's supposed to be a deterrent, but it extreme.


Correct me if I'm wrong, but with a red card for a hand-ball in the box, the following happens:


Team that commits hand-ball: Loses one man for the rest of the match and has that player suspended for the next game.

Team that had the infraction committed against them: Gets a man up for the rest of the game (baring any other red cards) AND gets a PK.


Getting a PK and having the opponent receive a yellow card seems more than enough. But, not only do they get a PK in this situation, they play the rest of the game a man up, baring any other cards.....

It doesn’t always favor the opposing team. In 2010 Luis Suarez slapped a clear goal and received a red card and out of the game.


Ghana still missed the PK and lost the game

 

[TheGreatShowtime]

Don't they only give out a red card for a hand ball if it prevented a goal/shot on goal from happening? That's pretty deserving of a suspension because it's pretty much flat out cheating since it was done intentionally.

I didn't see what happened in Japan/Colombia though

 

[Baka's Weird Case]

its only a red if it stops a clear goal. considering the most obvious thing that makes soccer soccer is not being able to use your hands using your hands to stop an otherwise goal is a serious violation of the rules. the suspension is important to deter people from attempting

 

[3rdLetter]

Don't they only give out a red card for a hand ball if it prevented a goal/shot on goal from happening? That's pretty deserving of a suspension because it's pretty much flat out cheating since it was done intentionally.

I didn't see what happened in Japan/Colombia though

Yea. More often then not, most handballs in the box don't even result in a card but just a pk. Handballs happen and not every one is on purpose but you still get punished for it.