This is the correct response. Some women like makeup regardless of how it makes them look. If she’s a makeup girl, she’s going to want to wear it. If she’s only wearing it to attract men, then she’ll do what you want. But if she has other qualities you like, will makeup matter?
This is why I’m not a “qualities matter more than looks” breh. If she had all the qualities you want, but she wears makeup, does that disqualify her? If you have a strong physical qualification that matters, would you forgo that for personality?