How the hell did Talia know Bruce Wayne was Batman?

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

Her and Bane didn't train the same time as Wayne.

Her daddy didn't even know he was Batman until he arrived in Gotham...

So he either called her when his dojo was destroyed which is highly unlikely or when he got to Gotham he somehow called her up and told her but that wouldn't make sense either.


Her daddy wanted to kill the people while preserving the land. Her plan called for destroying the city and surrounding area making it un inhabitable for decades I don't think that's what he had in mind.


:edit:

Wrong place

 

[mozichrome]

Obviously Ra’s Al Ghul knew, but when exactly did he transmit this news to his daughter? It isn’t too much of a problem to believe that Ra’s somehow got word to his daughter who was part of the League of Shadows, even if they were estranged over Ra’s shunning of Bane, but the absence of any explanation felt like a missing jigsaw piece when Talia revealed her true identity.

It’s not even certain Talia and Ra’s were fully estranged, given the fact that the script doesn’t just have her attempt to kill Batman and wipe Gotham off the map as a simple act of vengeance – she shares her father’s ideology, and his desire to eradicate Gotham’s excess after all. She wants to continue his work, and not merely atone for his absence in her life.

So presumably at some point Talia learned of Bruce Wayne’s secret double life through the League of Shadows network of information, but there is no suggestion of that in the script. And in a film in which verbose exposition is valued above all else, that has to be counted as an over-sight.

from google search

 

[Toe Jay Simpson]

You've got to imagine at that high of a level there is no such thing as a secret. Even in real life when the president takes a dump in a foreign country on certain occasions they have to deal with it themselves because of what the enemy can learn from his excrement. Bruce Wayne was a billionaire, the League just off that would have probably known everything there was to know about him due to his status in society. Wayne Enterprises probably had low level League affiliates working in there from day one; that's part of what they do in society.

I'm sure he had basic guys like Joker, Scarecrow, and all them fooled...but Ra's organization had been keeping tabs on the dealings of entire world in secret. It would have come through the wire so to speak.

 

[observe]

I don't get how people don't know who most of these super heros are ..like superman..how the fukk can you hide your identity with a pair of glasses..people recognize celebrities like kanye and brad Pitt when they're wearing shades..and people can't recognize superman who is known around?

 

[The Devil's Advocate]

Her and Bane didn't train the same time as Wayne.

Her daddy didn't even know he was Batman until he arrived in Gotham...

So he either called her when his dojo was destroyed which is highly unlikely or when he got to Gotham he somehow called her up and told her but that wouldn't make sense either.


Her daddy wanted to kill the people while preserving the land. Her plan called for destroying the city and surrounding area making it un inhabitable for decades I don't think that's what he had in mind.


:edit:

Wrong place

raz got bruce out of jail.... and bruce told him his entire backstory of how "even when he stole, it was from himself" when he took the shyt from wayne enterprises

matter of fact when he got him out of jail he called him bruce wayne and explained how he'd have to travel even farther if he wanted to go unnoticed

that and he said "return to gotham to burn it down" which is why bruce burned up the dojo

plus the fact he seen his real face for weeks or months and could easily tell who he was when he got to gotham... but that's irrelevant cause he knew before that

theeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen... it was bane who was kicked out.. not talia.. he could have told her at any point and time he wanted to.. left a note to be opened in case he failed... all that shyt


what movie were you watching??

 

[PrinceDeeDer]

 

[DamonDashsRocAFellaChain]

I can't even watch this movie without laughing. I love the series but goddamn

 

[NubianVitruvian]

Batman Can't Stop Thinking About Sex - CollegeHumor Video

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

raz got bruce out of jail.... and bruce told him his entire backstory of how "even when he stole, it was from himself" when he took the shyt from wayne enterprises

matter of fact when he got him out of jail he called him bruce wayne and explained how he'd have to travel even farther if he wanted to go unnoticed

that and he said "return to gotham to burn it down" which is why bruce burned up the dojo

plus the fact he seen his real face for weeks or months and could easily tell who he was when he got to gotham... but that's irrelevant cause he knew before that

theeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen... it was bane who was kicked out.. not talia.. he could have told her at any point and time he wanted to.. left a note to be opened in case he failed... all that shyt


what movie were you watching??

If she hated Bruce so much why did she fukk him then Was it really crucial for her to give up the box? She didn't need too. Her plan was already working.

 

[The Devil's Advocate]

If she hated Bruce so much why did she fukk him then Was it really crucial for her to give up the box? She didn't need too. Her plan was already working.

it literally cut him deeper... what hurts more?? some employee who you believed in, stabbing you in the back... and i'm not even meaning all these puns lol.. but i think nolan did... anyways


fukked over by some employee you trusted vs. fukked over by some employee you trusted, busted nuts in, and had you damn near falling in love



i'm not saying it was the greatest plot ever.. but those two parts made sense


now the real question is.. tell me how talia got out of that pit... nobody ever in history made it out... but you telling me a kid about 7-8 could jump farther than grown men come on nolan

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

it literally cut him deeper... what hurts more?? some employee who you believed in, stabbing you in the back... and i'm not even meaning all these puns lol.. but i think nolan did... anyways


fukked over by some employee you trusted vs. fukked over by some employee you trusted, busted nuts in, and had you damn near falling in love



i'm not saying it was the greatest plot ever.. but those two parts made sense


now the real question is.. tell me how talia got out of that pit... nobody ever in history made it out... but you telling me a kid about 7-8 could jump farther than grown men come on nolan

It aint cut deep. He was gonna smash catwoman eventually. He wasn't in love. Rachel working for the Joker would've been more realistic. I don't think Talia was ever in the pit to begin with.

 

[TooLazyToMakeUp1]

@ Batman walking on the iced over river to save Gordon just in time

And the battle between the malnourished police and Bane's crew (with tumbler tanks and automatic rifles) having hand to hand combat in the street

 

[Da Jungles]

@ people trying to make sense of comic book movies.

 

[Constantine]

This ain't rocket science brehs. Gotham is an archipelago with 5, or 7 islands all connected to each other by bridges, or tunnels. Gotham is analogous to NY with all of its Burroughs. It only seems logical that after Batman Begins, some of the League of Assassins escaped the Gotham PD dragnet, and went to Talia and told her what occurred Explaining how Talia found out is exposition; the movie was already two hours and forty five minutes; explaining how she found out would've taken what, an extra five, ten minutes, then you would have people complaining the movie was too long, instead of how Talia found out Bruce Wayne is Batman.

 

[Phoenix_Knightly23]

If she hated Bruce so much why did she fukk him then Was it really crucial for her to give up the box? She didn't need too. Her plan was already working.

Terrible argument. lol