i now think american gangster is jay's 3rd best album. 1. rd 2. blueprint 3. american gangster

[CrimsonTider]

I never liked this album

In My Lifetime, Vol. 1 is better

I like the album

But it is easily his most boring album

 

[RocPG]

Agreed, his catalog is top 5 easily. I always wondered about the line in "All I Need", "Read the rap sheet nikka three classics". I wonder if he was referring to RD, Vol. 1, and BP, RD, Vol. 2, and BP, RD, Vol. 3, and BP, RD, Dynasty, and BP, you get the idea

bolded...he said Vol 2 is one of his classics just of impact alone

 

[Awesome Wells]

Very dope album.

But I still think Reasonable Doubt, The Blueprint, and The Black Album are his three best joints.

 

[DJ Mart-Kos]

I think BP 2 is his 3d best

 

[Formerly known as...]

I agree with this. The album is solid and underrated as fukk!

 

[Farrinto]

bolded...he said Vol 2 is one of his classics just of impact alone

It might not be an undoubtable classic but it's definitely one of my personal classics Vol. 2 is a great album.

 

[Billy Ocean]

It's my third favorite behind RD and Blueprint. I always felt that the Black Album was overrated.

 

[CaughtInTWebb]

Like a other poster said...as the years pass Black Album isn't as good as items when it first dropped....

AG is just

 

[DJ Mart-Kos]

BP 2 is better.

 

[Da_Eggman]

No Hook is as dope a song as jay has ever done. What I love about jay is his gangsta shyt is never screamed or shouted, its always reasoned and persuaded.

Like Obama people are finally gonna appreciate jay. The nikka been missing and yall took that man for granted. People seen trump and clinton and feel bad for ever coming at Obama.

Reasonable Doubt 5mics
The Black Album 5 mics
Vol 1 5 mics
Blueprint 5 mics
American Gangster 4.5 mics
The Dynasty 4.5 mics
Watch The Throne 4.5 mics (jays contributions anyway)
BP2 4 mics
Vol 2 4 mics
Vol 3 4 mics
MCHG 4 mics ( the weak shyt is weak, but 3 or 4 joints really resonate with me)
BP3 3.5 mics
KC 3 mics.

Kc was solid man that album is unfairly hated on

 

[JMurder]

I'm not sure what makes TBA in consideration for top 3 Hov albums.

 

[big bun]

AG is my second favorite Camel record behind RD.

 

[Ziggiy]

If it ain't better than The Black Album it's the closest one....

 

[NV-ME]

highly debatable, but its aged very well




















...even though he talkin the same drug dealin shyt he always had