Illmatic + It Was Written vs. Ready To Die + Life After Death vs. Reasonable Doubt + The Blueprint

[Soymuscle Mike]

Yep

This thread got me thinking though on which 2 albums of Pack I’d choose between MATW, AEOM and 7DT for this thread it’s not easy choice

Illmatic + IWW > MATW + AYOM = AYOM + Makaveli >> RTD + LAD >>>>> RD + bp1

 

[ImmaGetJoeClarkArrested]

As much as I hate to say it...I gotta go wit big

 

[⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐]

Why does only one artist have the luxury of altering the selection from the freshman + sophomore format?

 

[XannyWarbucks]

RTD & LAD >ILL (Best Album out of all) & IWW > RD & BP

Criteria is all fukked up though, why put RD and BP, should be RD and Vol 1, even though it'd still end up the same.

Also happen to be my top-3, which would be Jay>Big>Nas

 

[TheGregReaper]

I vote for Illmatic + It Was Written

If I had to rank all the albums on the list I'd go....

1. Illmatic
2. Life After Death
3. It Was Written
4. Blueprint
5. Ready to Die
6. Reasonable Doubt

 

[I love Latina women]

RTD & LAD >ILL (Best Album out of all) & IWW > RD & BP

Criteria is all fukked up though, why put RD and BP, should be RD and Vol 1, even though it'd still end up the same.

Also happen to be my top-3, which would be Jay>Big>Nas

Because's it's not 1 of Jay's best albums.
Vol. 1 ain't fukking with The Blueprint as an album, as a whole project.
Jay was spitting better on Vol. 1 but as a whole album, from start 2 finish, The Blueprint is the better album.

 

[DJ Mart-Kos]

Think i'm going with Reasonable Doubt and Blueprint simply cause i think Jay is the best rapper out of the 3 personally.

 

[prophecypro]

1. Big
2. Nas
3. Jay

in that order

Its all pretty close and at the top though

 

[dem bath salts]

Ready to Die
Life After death
It was written
Blueprint
Reasonable Doubts

 

[Big Mark]

Easily Illmatic and IWW. Those two alums have the most combined certified classics than the other two. Nas was lyrically superior to both of the others on that

 

[ILLMMORTAL]