In your opinion why diddy I need a girl pt2 is more popular than pt1

[BlackonBlackCrime]

I mean usher was one the most biggest r&B singers in that time period

 

[Roid Jones]

Because Diddy is not #HOH

 

[Swagnificent]

not to me. i always liked part 1 better and its still one of my favorite RnB songs ever.

 

[aXiom]

Becuase of the whole puffy/jlo break up drama.. Part 1 was the better song though.

 

[TL15]

That little electric guitar
The way that they were always "harmonizing" over each others lyrics made it easier to sing along with
It's more uptempo
Ginuwine was killin it
The video was more poppin

 

[606onit]

One is better imo
1

2

 

[Kenny West]

its just better. it's got the groove
plus the hook .

 

[Buckeye Fever]

One is better to me.

But the songs were perfect, situationally.

1=the hurt of breaking up with a girl

2=pickin yaself up off the ground and gettin back out there finding another girl

Then, she will eventually cheat, and you are back to songs like

mario winans - i don't wanna know:

 

[AkaDemiK]

both are classics...1 is my favorite out of the two...can't go wrong with either

edit:

@Buckeye Fever another classic

 

[Cheercomp]

Only the real know that the video version with Usher is actually a remix of the original "I Need a Girl" from "The Saga Continues". I remember snatching Part 2 off the net at least 3 weeks before radio got it.... I played it out the whip during my senior promenade Had folks asking me "What was that jam u were blasting??" The joys of internet piracy in the early 2000s

 

[Black]

 

[GollyImGully]

part 2 got that knock :OhGawd:

 

[Illuminatos]

Part 2 is a classic.

 

[ORDER_66]

Part 1 is legendary for that beat and hook alone though... shyt still gets play,.....

 

[Mr210]

I dont remember which version was 1 and which was 2