Is Andy Reid a HOF Coach?

[MAGNETO.]

If not, what do you think it takes? Obviously a Super Bowl but I was wondering given his body of work and what he has done in Philadelphia and Kansas City, not an easy feat by any means, does he get in as currently constituted. He hasn't finished coaching and I understand that, but was just curious to see how theColi views Andy Reid as a coach.

 

[King Poetic]

If tom Flores can't get in with 2 super bowls with the raiders and a 8 - 3 playoff record and even a over 500 winning regular season record, andy shouldn't get in

 

[Formerly known as...]

He needs to maybe get this Chiefs team to a SB.

He has done a good job with the Chiefs since joining and he's built a decent squad

 

[1thouwow]

We miss you Andy

 

[Pete Wrigley]

After he wins the Super Bowl this year, he will definitely be in the discussion.

@GPBear

 

[MJ Truth]

If he was an NBA coach with his type of resume he'd already been in the Hall.

 

[MikelArteta]

Marty schottenheimer

200 wins 163 losses 60 percent winning percentage

In 21 years of coaching only 2 seasons with fewer than 8 wins

But couldn't get it done in the post season

 

[gangreen]

Great Coach, but without the chip. He not HOF.

He had his best chance to win a chip in philly in the early 2000s with mcnabb. He had the defense and a franchise quarterback.

He just needed to add that receiver to get them over the hump but he delayed until it was too late.

So if he doesnt win one, he is not hof.

 

[threattonature]

I think a Super Bowl win and he gets in cause he has the rest of the resume. I wouldn't vote him in now because of how many games he's blown in crucial moments with poor clock management.

 

[Remote]

Andy Reid is currently 12th all-time for most wins in NFL history.
The only active head coach ahead of him is Bill Belichick.

Technically, Andy Reid HAS won a super bowl -- he was the O-line coach with the Packers in 1996-1997.

Just because the NFL is retarded and refuses to elect Marty Schottenheimer does not mean Andy Reid isn't one of the best head coaches of all-time and deserves to be in the HOF.
This league is awful as it is by not electing Terrell Owens yet.

 

[JLova]

Needs to win a SB and I hope to God it isn't this year.