Is CC Sabathia a Hall of Famer?

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
81,947
Reputation
25,234
Daps
369,827
Perhaps the bar has been set unrealistically high for the HOF after having seen the likes of Maddux, Bonds, Clemens and Pedro.

But as Sabathia nears 37 years of age in 6 weeks, it begs the question: Is he a future Hall of Famer?

To consider:

2001 Rookie of the Year runner up after going 17-5.
6 time All Star
World Series Champion (2009)
ALCS MVP (2009)
Cy Young Award winner (2007) ...and finished in the Top 5 four other times.
229 - 143 W/L (as of this posting)
2,779 strikeouts (as of this posting -- good for 21st all-time)
MLB Wins leader (2009, 2010)

To some it may seem obvious that he belongs in the Hall.
For the record, I think he belongs on the 1st ballot.

But for many baseball fans, he never really got the type of fanfare and hype that other pitchers received during his career (Johan, Lincecum, Verlander, Felix), so I can see how CC may have flown under the radar a bit.
 

Jesus Is Lord

Give Thanks, Repent, and Forgive
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,414
Reputation
6,112
Daps
67,169
Reppin
Christ
221 Ks short of the automatic. Besides that, I'm on the fence leaning towards "nay".
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
81,947
Reputation
25,234
Daps
369,827
I'm surprised at all the "No" votes.

What exactly do you guys think the HOF baseline actually is? :heh:
Because it's not Tom Seaver, I can guarantee you that.
 
Top