is evan turner foe greg monroe a fair trade?

[john goodman]

Who wins that trade?

 

[Buckeye Fever]

Detroit wins that trade

 

[#1 pick]

Detroit, Evan is a top 5 SG and those are hard to find. Monroe is a top 15 PF who is good and can be very good but give me Evan. Philly needs a PF but not at the expense of Turner, MCW, or Hawes.

 

[Eastside Get The Money]

I don't want Turner on my team

 

[john goodman]

Detroit, Evan is a top 5 SG and those are hard to find. Monroe is a top 15 PF who is good and can be very good but give me Evan. Philly needs a PF but not at the expense of Turner, MCW, or Hawes.

Interesting

My gut reaction is id rather keep turner but I havent watched alot of monroe

 

[NatiboyB]

turner wasnt a top 5 sg until this 10 game stretch.ill take moose.

 

[Dayco23]

Turner is in his contract year, which is the only reason why he's putting up numbers. After he gets paid he will go back to being the scrub that he has been since he was drafted.

And he is NOT a top 5 SG.

Sixers would win that trade.

 

[Leasy]

Turner is in his contract year, which is the only reason why he's putting up numbers. After he gets paid he will go back to being the scrub that he has been since he was drafted.

And he is NOT a top 5 SG.

Sixers would win that trade.

Nope it's call the Doug Collins effect ask Rip Jordan G.Hill

 

[O.iatlhawksfan]

Honestly I can't think of 5 much less 10 PFs who have as much talent and upside as Monroe

 

[cleanface coney]

decent trade but i dont want him

 

[Brozay]

im still not convinced turner is a high level player

hes not a very good playmaker and his shooting % will start to regress as the season goes on

hes good but monroe has much more upside here



also, the pistons need a 3 that can shoot if they really want to move either smith or monroe.

 

[Kliq_Souf]

why trade for Monroe when Noel and Moultrie will be back next year

 

[Miggs]

Id rather have Monroe...

 

[Regular_P]

Detroit gets worse because they add yet another perimeter player who can't hit 3s.

 

[NormanConnors]

so we need another guard