is the black album still really a classic album?

Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
274,621
Reputation
69,031
Daps
599,801
Why yes, yes it is

:ld:

have you listened to it recently? :usure:


I like the album but it hasn't aged very well.

exactly, a lot of the beats on this album don't sound anywhere as great as they did in 2003

"december 4th" is 1
"what more can i say" is another
"dirt off your shoulders"
"change clothes"
"my 1st song"

^none^ of these have held up well:scusthov:

plus, jay z didn't even really retire. i can't take away the fact that jay was spittin' on most of these tracks but the album hasn't aged well at all :manny:
 

Buckeye Fever

YOU WILL ALL HAIL TO THE VICTORS!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
85,461
Reputation
46,210
Daps
397,215
Reppin
Hip-Hop Since '79
have you listened to it recently? :usure:




exactly, a lot of the beats on this album don't sound anywhere as great as they did in 2003

december 4th is 1
what more can i say is another
dirt off your shoulders
change clothes
my 1st song

^none^ of these have held up great :scusthov:

plus, jay z didn't even really retire. i can't take away the fact that jay was spittin' on most of these tracks but the album hasn't aged well at all :manny:
At work bout to bump it now:birdman:


Out of those song you listed, the only one that didnt age well to me was Dirt Off Your Shoulders. One of Timbaland's worst beats:yeshrug:
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
274,621
Reputation
69,031
Daps
599,801
At work bout to bump it now:birdman:


Out of those song you listed, the only one that didnt age well to me was Dirt Off Your Shoulders. One of Timbaland's worst beats:yeshrug:

naw, you'll see what i'm sayin' once you go back and listen, this really doesn't sound good anymore :yeshrug:

i meant to add "moment of clarity" too :scusthov:

i can vividly remember how many people were ridin' so hard (pause) for this album too. myself included :heh:
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
274,621
Reputation
69,031
Daps
599,801
That's the main thing that hurts this album.

If you're retiring from rap, retire then...Don't pop up every 3 months spittin guest feature verse
on other rappers albums.

yup, it makes the album just a vanity project and a quick cash in

but more importantly, it takes away the the album's whole meanin', but aside from that, the album really hasn't held up well anyway :manny:
 

Buckeye Fever

YOU WILL ALL HAIL TO THE VICTORS!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
85,461
Reputation
46,210
Daps
397,215
Reppin
Hip-Hop Since '79
naw, you'll see what i'm sayin' once you go back and listen, this really doesn't sound good anymore :yeshrug:

i meant to add "moment of clarity" too :scusthov:

i can vividly remember how many people were ridin' so hard (pause) for this album too. myself included :heh:
It's gonna always sound good:mjcry:
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
274,621
Reputation
69,031
Daps
599,801
It's gonna always sound good:mjcry:

i don't know man, maybe it's because i'm older now or somethin' but it don't wow (pause, lol) me like it did years ago

it's just kind of there, like blah to me now :yeshrug:

only jay z album i can put on and really vibe out to still is reasonable doubt; part of the blueprint is cool and i rode hard (pause) for that album back then but now aside from a few songs like "heart of the song", "song cry", "momma loves me", "breathe easy", and "u don't know" i'm good :manny:

but ain't nothin' like crusin' late at night and listenin' to this :wow:





 

Buckeye Fever

YOU WILL ALL HAIL TO THE VICTORS!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
85,461
Reputation
46,210
Daps
397,215
Reppin
Hip-Hop Since '79
i don't know man, maybe it's because i'm older now or somethin' but it don't wow (pause, lol) me like it did years ago

it's just kind of there, like blah to me now :yeshrug:

only jay z album i can put on and really vibe out to still is reasonable doubt; part of the blueprint is cool and i rode hard (pause) for that album back then but now aside from a few songs like "heart of the song", "song cry", "momma loves me", "breathe easy", and "u don't know" i'm good :manny:

but ain't nothin' like crusin' late at night and listenin' to this :wow:






TBA just reminds me of when I moved from Illinois for the 1st time ever. Maybe that's why it holds a special status with me.

RD will always be his best album to most. I cant argue that
 
Top