Nah man everything don’t need to be open world man
I agree, but that’s the only way I can see a place like Catalina island being fun.
It’s big enough to explore and wander, but there isn’t enough there to be on the rails like the first TLOU; not even for the open arenas in the second one. It’s a lot of dry brush desert hills, wide open trails, a random soccer field, a very small air strip, and two small dock towns.
I really wouldn’t mind a densely packed, metro done like a combination of TLOU 1&2. New Orleans, Philly, Baltimore, DC and NYC would