problem with using criteria like that is it gets opened up to abuse. you get a rep group or whatever who decides they want to get rid of a certain posters ability to make threads so they go around 1 starring everything to skew the results.
right now, the mods and brook and I have to take it upon ourselves to do what we think is best for the forum and decide if what someone is creating for threads brings anything to the table. i personally look for people who make the same threads over and over, or ones who dont put any effort into the threads. as much as people might think the "snitch" button doesnt really do anything, we do take those into account. if we see a certain poster is getting reported all the time then we're more likely to take action. one of our warning actions is for "low quality posting" so the snitch link could be used to report threads that you think suck, rather than only rule violations
as a young and growing forum you get caught up in numbers and activity levels so you dont really mind a bunch of threads but you eventually reach a point where you need to start thinking about quality over quantity and we've definitely reached that point. its just a tricky situation because part of the essence of this board is the loose culture and we dont want to lose that. it makes it even more complicated when the board talks about how much they enjoy "fukkery" then in the next thread complain about all the trolling. my thought process is start at the bottom, either ban or limit the most horrific trolls and see if things improve and go from there.
