Is tina turner and janet jackson more complete artist than beyonce.

G-Zeus

G-Zeus Chrystler...the brehsident
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
18,642
Reputation
1,607
Daps
40,762
Reppin
Brehsident evil
you kind of name 3 artists who gets their song written ... JJ best dancer of the group..Beyonce best singer and i guess if TT was of the same age as either of them she would be number 2 in both ... but.. those are pop singers... its about the music mre than the artistique talent.
 

itsyoung!!

Veteran
Bushed
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,914
Reputation
6,665
Daps
110,427
Reppin
Bay Area
Beyonce is the best of her era. Leave it at that.

is she :jbhmm: or is it all hype :jbhmm:

album sales of her era she isnt top 5 :jbhmm: Lady Gaga, Adele, Rihanna, Nicki Minaj (someone correct me if im wrong on this one), Taylor Swift, etc all have sold more in the past 10 years.
top hits, she isnt top 5 :jbhmm: She actually gets killed in this catagory :huhldup: hits looking kinda shakey over her career.. 20 years in the game and really single ladies is her biggest hit, let that sink in :usure:

seems like theres plenty of room on that throne to be claimed :usure: Beyonce isnt undeniably #1 in any single catagory you could think of.. but social media would have you thinking other wise, but "women lie, men lie, numbers dont" :usure:

Objectively speaking, Rihanna seems to have had the overall better career.. Beyonce seems to have the biggest rabid fan base though

but the numbers look kinda funny in the light :usure:
 

Rekkapryde

GT, LWO, 49ERS, BRAVES, HAWKS, N4O...yeah UMAD!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
155,685
Reputation
30,363
Daps
526,735
Reppin
TYRONE GA!
is she :jbhmm: or is it all hype :jbhmm:

album sales of her era she isnt top 5 :jbhmm: Lady Gaga, Adele, Rihanna, Nicki Minaj (someone correct me if im wrong on this one), Taylor Swift, etc all have sold more in the past 10 years.
top hits, she isnt top 5 :jbhmm: She actually gets killed in this catagory :huhldup: hits looking kinda shakey over her career.. 20 years in the game and really single ladies is her biggest hit, let that sink in :usure:

seems like theres plenty of room on that throne to be claimed :usure:

Objectively speaking, Rihanna seems to have had the overall better career.. Beyonce seems to have the biggest rabid fan base though

but the numbers look kinda funny in the light :usure:

:patrice:

But all of those artists don't write. We know Beyonce does.
All of those artists aren't great stage performers, Beyonce pretty much has that one with ease.
Open pro blackness. That's another W by far in Beyonce's book.
Longevity. Again, another W for Beyonce.
Only thing she doesn't have a W in is sales.
 

itsyoung!!

Veteran
Bushed
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,914
Reputation
6,665
Daps
110,427
Reppin
Bay Area
:patrice:

But all of those artists don't write. We know Beyonce does.
All of those artists aren't great stage performers, Beyonce pretty much has that one with ease.
Open pro blackness. That's another W by far in Beyonce's book.
Longevity. Again, another W for Beyonce.
Only thing she doesn't have a W in is sales.

beyonce dont fukking write :dead:

Dream write all her shyt :dead: he even wrote her biggest hit, Single Ladies :dead:

stop :dead:

longevity is the only thing she has but really everyone of those artists I named been around now over 10 years.. someone has to be around 1st, but theyve all been more successful :usure:
 

BlackDiBiase

Superstar
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
21,150
Reputation
-268
Daps
38,865
tina and janet both killed it in the radio era, if not for the music video no one would know beyonces msduic.

she hasnt had a hit since single ladies and that song was trash and once again if not for the video you have nothing.

poor singer songwritter, good performer, goat media game.
 

itsyoung!!

Veteran
Bushed
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,914
Reputation
6,665
Daps
110,427
Reppin
Bay Area
Cmon fam. I'm not a Beyonce fan, but you actin like she curved you.
Category:Songs written by Beyoncé - Wikipedia

nah I just think the hype is unjustified.. shes never been the biggest artist -- ever, but from media you would think shes sold 100 million records and had the most hits, but she not even top 5... people comparing her to MJ and shyt its just blasphemous

and that list can be anything when you are a writer if she wrote saya hook or changed a few words she still gets writer credit

as an example "Single Ladies" is on that list you just linked but we know 10000% fact Dream wrote majority of that song and gave to her

How The-Dream wrote Umbrella, Single Ladies, and other hits
 
Top