As a supporter of #SDSET, I have enjoyed nearly everything about the show and the booking has been great. It's hard to argue that. People are INVESTED in characters like Miz and Ziggler for the first time in a long time. The women's division, every female has a character and motivations. Slater has resurrected his career. :styles: has been THE main event in all of WWE. He has reached new heights for his career. CoDean is cutting the best promos of his WWE career. the heel turn for the Usos has revived their career.
So I would say yeah, from an entertainment standpoint and a booking standpoint, SDL has been a success. They are trying new things and they are letting people get into their characters.
But all that said, I will admit that SDL is also graded on a curve. It's doing well FOR Tuesdays. The ratings are good FOR Tuesday night and the 18-49 demographic number is good.
But obviously it's not going to be viewed the same because it isn't Monday and I acknowledge that.
RAW hasn't hit its stride. Balor injury was an issue. But look at the feuds right now. Nobody is in a better place now than prior to the draft outside of Owens/Jericho. The women are doing well but it's being driven into the ground. The cruisers are only getting 2 minute matches and very little in character development. The tag division is a bit stagnant. Rollins is stagnant. Steph and Mick all over the shows. Nobody wants to see them. Reigns is still floundering as well. So far I'd say:
SDL - A (but graded on a curve, not an A+ because of Bray/Orton/Kane shyt)
RAW - C-