Josh Allen.....STAR or BUST? (vote now)

[Swagnificent]

Every time this dude's name is mentioned, I hear almost everyone saying he's gonna be a bust in the NFL. Well I wanna see ya'll put ya names on the line and vote on this RIGHT NOW. I don't wanna see the revisionist history that is bound to happen in the coming years when Josh Allen is tearing up the NFL and nikkas is gonna pretend like they saw it all along.

Tell us all RIGHT NOW where you stand on Josh Allen. Will he be a STAR or a BUST?

I think we can all agree that Josh Allen is not gonna be average. He's boom or bust. Ya'll already know where I stand on this. I had Josh Allen rated as the #1 QB in the 2018 NFL Draft so you obviously know what I voted for in this poll. With regard to the other QBs in this class, this is how I have them ranked.

Swag's 2018 NFL Draft QB Rankings:
1. Josh Allen (Bills) - NFL comp: Dan Marino w/ mobility
2. Lamar Jackson (Ravens) - NFL comp: Michael Vick w/ better passing instincts
3. Sam Darnold (Jets) - NFL comp: Matt Stafford w/ less arm strength
4. Josh Rosen (Cardinals) - NFL comp: Eli Manning w/ durability concerns
5. Kyle Lauletta (Giants) - NFL comp: Alex Smith
6. Logan Woodside (Bengals) - NFL comp: Jon Kitna
7. Baker Mayfield (Browns) - NFL comp: Rex Grossman
8. Riley Ferguson (Bucaneers)
9. Mike White (Cowboys)
10. Luke Falk (Titans)

Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson will be the biggest stars from this QB class. Sam Darnold and Josh Rosen will be solid franchise QBs. Kyle Lauletta and Logan Woodside will be the huge steals. And obviously Baker Mayfield will be the biggest bust. My deep sleeper is Riley Ferguson. He went undrafted but I believe he has the talent to play in this league.

 

[#1 pick]

That's game

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

Mark me down for bust

 

[yseJ]

way more of a chance of a bust. big arm, shytty accuracy and a mess under pressure dont bode well in todays nfl

his mobility may take some by surprise, but cat will be out of the bag in a year or two

 

[AlphaOne]

A big fukking bust.

Thread is gonna be upped for years to prove your flawless taste is

Dap me future brehs

 

[Swagnificent]

Mark me down for bust

Good. Hopefully I'm the only one who votes STAR. That way when Josh Allen is a STAR in the NFL, I'll be able to laugh in all ya'lls faces.

 

[Swagnificent]

way more of a chance of a bust. big arm, shytty accuracy and a mess under pressure dont bode well in todays nfl

his mobility may take some by surprise, but cat will be out of the bag in a year or two

That's one of the biggest myths of all-time. Can't wait till he disproves that in year 1.

Josh Allen has ZERO issues with accuracy. He's probably the second most accurate passer in this class of the 1st round QBs after Josh Rosen.

 

[Swagnificent]

Thread is gonna be upped for years to prove your flawless taste is

More like it'll be just another piece of evidence that shows I'm by far the best evaluator of talent anywhere on this planet.

Just watch and see. Josh Allen will rip apart the NFL and every one of ya'll will be thinking to yourself how silly you were for ever doubting him or me. From now on ya'll are gonna learn that whoever I say is gonna be good will be good. Word to Alvin Kamara.

 

[Bigblackted4]

Voted bust if I’m wrong I’ll admit it but accuracy issues with perfect mechanics don’t work

 

[yseJ]

That's one of the biggest myths of all-time. Can't wait till he disproves that in year 1.

Josh Allen has ZERO issues with accuracy. He's probably the second most accurate passer in this class of the 1st round QBs after Josh Rosen.

stop trolling. hes missing his rbs and tes in the flat by 3 yards on 5 yard throws. not once per season, not once per game, but several times per game

dude has all attributes of a mobile kyle boller

 

[Panther]

Bust

 

[Swagnificent]

Voted bust if I’m wrong I’ll admit it but accuracy issues with perfect mechanics don’t work

Once again that is a total myth. Josh Allen is a very accurate passer. I've actually watched his tape rather than just taking some clown on TV's word for it. Josh Allen did not play in an air raid or spread offense like Baker Mayfield that affords the QB all these easy throws that help inflate the completion %. Josh Allen was almost always making big boy throws that were NFL caliber. His offensive line and receivers weren't great either so he was not getting much time to go through his progressions or his receivers weren't getting much separation. Also, he's a bit of a gun-slinger. So he would constantly be looking to make the big play downfield rather than taking the wide open check down. That is not an issue of accuracy. Its an issue with decision-making that can easily be corrected.

I can't wait till Josh Allen is throwing dimes all over the field in the NFL so that this myth is finally buried.

 

[Swagnificent]

stop trolling. hes missing his rbs and tes in the flat by 3 yards on 5 yard throws. not once per season, not once per game, but several times per game

dude has all attributes of a mobile kyle boller

FALSE. The easy throws he misses are no more common than any other QB. However, what is uncommon about him is the number of big time throws down the field that he makes. He's gonna make throws in the NFL that will make Aaron Rodgers look like a Pee Wee football player. His arm is that incredible.

Just wait and see. Ya'll gonna be Juelzing like a muthafukka in a few months when dude is ripping apart the NFL.

 

[Bigblackted4]

Once again that is a total myth. Josh Allen is a very accurate passer. I've actually watched his tape rather than just taking some clown on TV's word for it. Josh Allen did not play in an air raid or spread offense like Baker Mayfield that affords the QB all these easy throws that help inflate the completion %. Josh Allen was almost always making big boy throws that were NFL caliber. His offensive line and receivers weren't great either so he was not getting much time to go through his progressions or his receivers weren't getting much separation. Also, he's a bit of a gun-slinger. So he would constantly be looking to make the big play downfield rather than taking the wide open check down. That is not an issue of accuracy. Its an issue with decision-making that can easily be corrected.

I can't wait till Josh Allen is throwing dimes all over the field in the NFL so that this myth is finally buried.

I never base opinions off mainstream media I watch scouting guys that breakdown the plays. He throws some of the most beautiful balls I’ve ever seen and then comes back and throws wild high or far. I actually don’t that’s bl he’ll be a bust but won’t be near a top 20 qb

 

[calh45]

He's been inaccurate since junior college. It ain't magically going away because you compare him to Marino.