I agree. Even as an 11 year old in '06, I knew what was good and what was trash, and the good definitely outweighed the trash in that period. Internet hip hop nerds just ran with the whole "hip hop is dead" concept throughout the late 2000's, being willfully ignorant of the high amount of quality music coming out. Mainly because folks on the internet were still on that corny "southern rappers are trash" shyt, and hated on nikkas like Jeezy, Gucci, Wayne, ect., saying they "killed" hip hop because they weren't rapping over early 90's boom bap beats, and didn't talk like NY nikkas
Folks like Plies, Jeezy, Gucci, Wayne, Rick Ross, T.I., and Three 6 Mafia were going platinum. One hit wonder nikkas flopped because people knew they were trash. nikkas acted like all southern rap sounded like Laffy Taffy and A Bay Bay. They didn't want to listen to southern rap until the mainstream forced them to. I can definitely argue that the artists I listed are just as lyrical as any other 2000's rapper. Lyrical rap never died, nikkas down south always made lyrical rap, along with club shyt. NY's sound just got stale, and they hated on us, until they started jocking us