Marshall Mathers LP Vs. Supreme Clientele

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
35,768
Reputation
13,249
Daps
137,080
Reppin
T.L.C.
Grounds for comparison:

- Both official sophomore solo efforts
- Both were released in 2000
- Both are considered great lyricists within the genre.
- There are about an even amount of actual songs, which makes good for track for track comparisons.

I kinda make it a habit to revisit and sit with older albums at least once a month. I'll look through my CD's or storage drives and just pick one at random and rock with it, or at least see how long I can. I was recently doing this SC and I can't really say it's striking me as some sort of landmark, classic album although it gets ranked that way by some. I see similar arguments for/against MMLP as well so I figured I'd do a little track by track play through.

As I stated they almost have the same amount of songs if you include "The kids" as a bonus, so I went ahead and threw that on there, left out the skits and let the songs ride track for track.

1. Kill you = Nutmeg (love both songs for different reasons, can't pick)
2. Stan > One
3. Who Knew > Saturday Nite
4. The way I am > Ghost Deni
5. The real slim shady < Apollo kids
6. Remember me > The grain
7. Im back < buck 50
8. Marshall Mathers = Mighty healthy
9. Drug ballad = Stay true
10. Ammityville < We made it (love both of these records, bizzare's verse gives ghost advantage here)
11. bytch please 2 < Stroke of death
12. Kim > Malcom
13. Under the influence < Childs play
14. Criminal > cherechez la ghost
15. The kids < Wu banga 101

This is of course all up for debate but on the low this is really an appreciation thread for two albums that have made their way back into rotation for me.



Sticky on this :whoo:


I could play this shyt 20 times without wanting to switch tracks....Rza :ohlawd:
 

NoHalfWay

Superstar
Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Messages
16,061
Reputation
2,765
Daps
53,176
Reppin
813
1. Kill you < Nutmeg
2. Stan < One
3. Who Knew > Saturday Nite
4. The way I am < Ghost Deni
5. The real slim shady < Apollo kids
6. Remember me > The grain
7. Im back < buck 50
8. Marshall Mathers < Mighty healthy
9. Drug ballad = Stay true
10. Ammityville < We made it
11. bytch please 2 < Stroke of death
12. Kim < Malcom
13. Under the influence < Childs play
14. Criminal > cherechez la ghost
15. The kids < Wu banga 101
Fixed that for you. Supreme Clientele by a landslide
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
53,781
Reputation
20,450
Daps
294,444
mwv9LO3.gif

SC by a mile. And I really like MMLP.
 

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
35,768
Reputation
13,249
Daps
137,080
Reppin
T.L.C.
supreme clientele is low key one of the best albums EVER in hip hop history. MM is cool but its not touching supreme. supreme is just too much flavor

I dunno man, like I said I sat with it for about a week and half and really ended up only gravitating to a couple joints, nutmeg is like my stuffed animal though, I can't make any kind of "rippity rap" :krs: mix without throwing that on there.

I thought maybe I'd catch something I missed initially but I can't say I love the album, Ironman is a different story though.
 

ZEB WALTON

ayo! - BEZ
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
10,946
Reputation
956
Daps
18,928
Reppin
No Father To MY Style.. A Son Unique
I dunno man, like I said I sat with it for about a week and half and really ended up only gravitating to a couple joints, nutmeg is like my stuffed animal though, I can't make any kind of "rippity rap" :krs: mix without throwing that on there.

I thought maybe I'd catch something I missed initially but I can't say I love the album, Ironman is a different story though.
childs play and mighty healthy alone are so classic ...idk.. we made it... saturday night. the beats. the rhyme styles. classic wu shyt like buck 50 and wu banga 101.. i cant give em this one. not this one
 

bordeaux

xxx
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
7,816
Reputation
825
Daps
16,862
Reppin
God's Plan
supreme clientele. looking at your comparisons, all ghosts songs r better except criminal maybe. no poll, why?
 

Diunx

Probably drunk
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
15,641
Reputation
2,163
Daps
46,310
Reppin
nightset
A little off topic but Bulletproof Wallets is a really underrated album.
 

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
35,768
Reputation
13,249
Daps
137,080
Reppin
T.L.C.


I lost my shyt when I first heard this song, like he was so on top of this beat, the ad-libs/doubles were hilarious and intense.
 
Top