Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Saw this mentioned It was really good IMO... 
Meltzer Gives Cody Rhodes vs. AJ Styles 5 Stars *****
- Thread starter Saysumthinfunnymike
- Start date
Saw this mentioned It was really good IMO... 
Toe Jay Simpson
Searchin’
Still dont mean SQUAT
Who cares what Meltzer thinks
And the match aint better than HBK vs Kurt Angle or Undertaker at Wrestlemania
And the match aint better than HBK vs Kurt Angle or Undertaker at Wrestlemania
Cattle Mutilation
Superstar
You basically have to treat Meltzer’s star ratings in two era. 2016 and earlier and then 2017 and later.
Five star matches were rare before 2017, now they happen like twice a month or more on average.
Like comparing NBA stats from the 90s to today. Two completely different eras.
Metal Face
Superstar
great match but ****1/2 at best
Trying too hard to beat the biased allegations 
Those 5 stars started popping up a lot more in 2019
Cattle Mutilation
Superstar
2018 had 21 five+ star matches, which obviously predates AEW.Trying too hard to beat the biased allegations
Those 5 stars started popping up a lot more in 2019
Excluding the 2020 plague year where there were only 12 five+ star matches, the average from 2019-2023 is 22.5
Alright imma chill
But Meltz not giving
any 5* match until he got to AEW is sus
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Alright imma chill
But Meltz not giving
We all know Meltz has had some WWE biases over the years but I'm shocked none of Bryan's ROH catalog has 5 stars. He ain't even give the match with Nigel 5?
Killah Ray
Carolina hail to thee....
5 star matches used to he impossible to get from Dave…when he gave Joe/Punk and Joe/Kobashi 5 stars the IWC went fukking insane…We all know Meltz has had some WWE biases over the years but I'm shocked none of Bryan's ROH catalog has 5 stars. He ain't even give the match with Nigel 5?
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Makes sense but it was still inconsistent because I believe he was giving a lot of 5 stars out to the All-Japan women's wrestling ...
OneDeep
Veteran
Never got why some people take his ratings to heart
They deserved it tho. Them chicks were innovating on another level at the time. Dave still doesn't give woman's matches today high ratings because it hasn't topped All Japan in his opinion.
Lol
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Not saying they didn't but he went overboard and then didn't give WWE a "5 star match" for like 20 years or something ridiculous like that.