My friend said Carmelo is a top 70 player all time...

[Versa]

I had a discussion with my boy about where Carmelo Anthony ranks among the all time great players. He said he was around top 70, and I said around top 40. This is the list we came up with of players above Melo right now. How accurate was our list ? It isn't in order for the record.

1. MJ
2. Bill Russel
3. Kareem
4. Kobe
5. Lebron
6. Bird
7. Magic
8. Duncan
9. Shaq
10. Haeekm
11. Dr J
12. Wade
13. KG
14. Barkley
15. Malone
16. West
17. Isaiah Thomas
18. David Robinson
19. Patrick Ewing
20. Kevin Mchale
21. Kevin Durant
22. Moses Malone
23. Oscar Robertson
24. Wilt Chamberlain
25. John Havlecic
26. Paul Pierce
27. Rick Barry
28. Ray Allen
29. Jason Kidd
30. Steve Nash
31. Dirk Nowitzki
32. Stephen Curry
33. Walt Frazier
34. Tracy McGrady
35. Pete Marovich
36. Gary Payton
37. Chris Webber
38. Tiny Archibal
39. Grant Hill
40. Reggie Miller
41. Scottie Pippen
42. Russell Westbrook
43. Chris Paul
44. Allen Iverson
45. Wes Unseld
46. Tony Parker
47. Chris Bosh
48. Karl Maone
49. John Stockton
50. Willis Reed
51. Dwight Howard
52. Clyde Drexler
53. Dominique Wilkins
54. Manu Ginoubli
55. Alonzo Mourning
56. CARMELO ANTHONY

 

[Carlos Huerta]

you both lost

 

[That Singer Guy...]

Top 50 probably...

 

[Brozay]

Let me pull up my top 70 list real quick...

 

[Youhadasparkwhenustarted]

He's somewhere in the 40-100 range

 

[Loose]

Your friends about right. Whole things subjective though. Imo tmac career >> melos and he's not even top 50

 

[EducatedBrothaFromTheBank]

Who the hell has time to argue over the top 70 players?

 

[ThaBronxBully]

Why The fukk Is McGrady On That List?

 

[spliz]

Your friends about right. Whole things subjective though. Imo tmac career >> melos

How is TMac's career better than Melo's?..this makes no sense and T Mac was one of my favorite players..the nikka never even got out of the 1st round..

 

[Pesci]

Pippen at 41

 

[Malta]

Wilt at 24 :Nahchillb:

Yall need to pick up badminton.

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

I had a discussion with my boy about where Carmelo Anthony ranks among the all time great players. He said he was around top 70, and I said around top 40. This is the list we came up with of players above Melo right now. How accurate was our list ? It isn't in order for the record.

1. MJ
2. Bill Russel
3. Kareem
4. Kobe
5. Lebron
6. Bird
7. Magic
8. Duncan
9. Shaq
10. Haeekm
11. Dr J
12. Wade
13. KG
14. Barkley
15. Malone
16. West
17. Isaiah Thomas

18. David Robinson
19. Patrick Ewing
20. Kevin Mchale
21. Kevin Durant
22. Moses Malone
23. Oscar Robertson
24. Wilt Chamberlain
​

25. John Havlecic
26. Paul Pierce
27. Rick Barry
28. Ray Allen
29. Jason Kidd
30. Steve Nash
31. Dirk Nowitzki
32. Stephen Curry
33. Walt Frazier
34. Tracy McGrady
35. Pete Marovich
36. Gary Payton
37. Chris Webber
38. Tiny Archibal
39. Grant Hill
40. Reggie Miller
41. Scottie Pippen
42. Russell Westbrook
43. Chris Paul
44. Allen Iverson
45. Wes Unseld
46. Tony Parker
47. Chris Bosh
48. Karl Maone
49. John Stockton
50. Willis Reed
51. Dwight Howard
52. Clyde Drexler
53. Dominique Wilkins
54. Manu Ginoubli
55. Alonzo Mourning
56. CARMELO ANTHONY

easily the worst list i've ever seen

 

[Juggalo Fred]

Your friends about right. Whole things subjective though. Imo tmac career >> melos and he's not even top 50

t mac never got out of the first round of the playoffs

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

dwanye wade over wilt chaimberlain is the funniest shyt ive seen all day

 

[Optimus Prime]

Pippen at 41

Wilt at 24 :Nahchillb:

Yall need to pick up badminton.

He said its NOT in order