My friend said Carmelo is a top 70 player all time...

[GreatestLaker]

nikka I said tmac's peak is better, Melo's career is already better than tmacs tho, who the fukk said Melo is good as prime kobe?

Tmac might have a higher peak than Melo but Melo already has had a better career than tmac.

His peak was only higher cause he was the better playmaker, Melo is the more efficient scorer

Nah dude. T-mac peaked higher because he was a MUCH BETTER player than Melo.

And I'm not buying that Melo had a better career either. T-Mac finished top 10 in MVP votes 6 times and the top 6 4 times compared to Melo 2 times in the top 10 and 1 time in the top 6.

T-Mac made the All-NBA first team twice and the second team 3 times compared to Melo zero times on the All-NBA first team and twice on the second team.

 

[Youngdev]

Nah dude. T-mac peaked higher because he was a MUCH BETTER player than Melo.

And I'm not buying that Melo had a better career either. T-Mac finished top 10 in MVP votes 6 times and the top 6 4 times compared to Melo 2 times in the top 10 and 1 time in the top 6.

T-Mac made the All-NBA first team twice and the second team 3 times compared to Melo zero times on the All-NBA first team and twice on the second team.

I know why he peaked higher nikka cause he was a better playmaker just like I said. Melo was a more efficient scorer and rebounding numbers were about even but tmac was a great playmaker which makes him the better player overall, I didn't dispute that. And if Melo's career isn't already better is gonna be better soon so

 

[Cyber]

He might be top 70 all-time career-wise but honestly once you get that far there's a ton of guys that are interchangeable. He could be around 50 or he could be closer to 100.

From an ability standpoint I feel that he's this generations Alex English and English probably cracks my top 50, so he might be top 50 in that regard and I can see his career rank there when he's done playing.

 

[Originalgangsta317]

I know why he peaked higher nikka cause he was a better playmaker just like I said. Melo was a more efficient scorer and rebounding numbers were about even but tmac was a great playmaker which makes him the better player overall, I didn't dispute that. And if Melo's career isn't already better is gonna be better soon so

fukk outta here

 

[Originalgangsta317]

He might be top 70 all-time career-wise but honestly once you get that far there's a ton of guys that are interchangeable. He could be around 50 or he could be closer to 100.

From an ability standpoint I feel that he's this generations Alex English and English probably cracks my top 50, so he might be top 50 in that regard and I can see his career rank there when he's done playing.

First part got the dap.

Second part,no,Melo is Bernard King all over again,straight scorer nothing more,nothing less, top 80

 

[Cyber]

First part got the dap.

Second part,no,Melo is Bernard King all over again,straight scorer nothing more,nothing less, top 80

Bernard King is also a very good comparison, especially when you look at their time with the Knicks.

 

[Osmosis]

Curry is ahead of him too

 

[Originalgangsta317]

fukk this nikka

 

[Versa]

Yeah. Like "yo nygga Kobe or Jordan, Griffey or Bonds, Rice or Moss" not "yo son who's in your too 75 players of all time"

Nah that's not how I went.

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Tmac and ai were jus glorified chucks breh

I agree. Pierce>>>> all three of them tho