Noah or a healthy Bogut....which one you taking??

[ahomeplateslugger]

let's talk about it

 

[StackBundles]

 

[So UnThotful]

Bogut.

and i hate australians too

 

[ahomeplateslugger]

noah is a better a rebounder and is one of the best big defenders. bogut wish he had noah's heart

 

[G.O.A.T Squad Spokesman]

noah is a better a rebounder and is one of the best big defenders. bogut wish he had noah's heart

Bogut is a better post defender believe it or not.

 

[ahomeplateslugger]

Bogut is a better post defender believe it or not.

the drop off from bogut's post defense to noah's post defense isnt huge or even noticable. bogut is just a bigger body so he takes up more space. noah is the better all around defender.

 

[StreetDawah]

Bogut but it's pretty close. Bogut may be a better post defender, but Noah makes up for in his pick and roll defense. For example, Noah defending Lebron in the ECF at times last year. Not many C's can do that. Bogut has better offensive game, but Noah has improved in that department of his game. I still think Noah hasn't reached his peak yet.

 

[yseJ]

saying "a healthy bogut" is akin to saying "a present day dinosaur"

neither thing exists

 

[Da King]

Bogut, not even close

 

[holidayinn21]

Bogut but it's pretty close. Bogut may be a better post defender, but Noah makes up for in his pick and roll defense. For example, Noah defending Lebron in the ECF at times last year. Not many C's can do that. Bogut has better offensive game, but Noah has improved in that department of his game. I still think Noah hasn't reached his peak yet.

noah is nice, but he has definitely peaked.

 

[Mr swag]

Bogut not even close


I see Noah is losing in the polls so I expect Chicago to lock or delete this thread

 

[ahomeplateslugger]

Bogut but it's pretty close. Bogut may be a better post defender, but Noah makes up for in his pick and roll defense. For example, Noah defending Lebron in the ECF at times last year. Not many C's can do that. Bogut has better offensive game, but Noah has improved in that department of his game. I still think Noah hasn't reached his peak yet.

noah with some offensive moves

saying "a healthy bogut" is akin to saying "a present day dinosaur"

neither thing exists

 

[jerniebert]

Ill take noah.

 

[Malta]

I'll take Noah, that injury Bogut sustained two years ago has really fukked up his game. He has a lot of trouble shooting jump hooks with his right now, if you've watched him since he came back from that injury almost every shot he takes in the paint is with his left hand now.

 

[Since '86]

Noah.