OK we are settling this with a poll, one game to win Tom Brady or Peyton Manning

[PremierDaTruth]

It's any playoff game with a random setting, could be a dome or 15 degrees with heavy snow.

No answer is wrong, this thread probably has been done before but maybe not this context. I'm curious to see the Colis overall stance on this. Who's your QB?!!?!?!?

 

[dh86]

The guy that's 17-7 or the guy that's 9-11? Come on.

 

[Jplaya2023]

do they have the

same defenses, same coach, same coaching staff????

before you answer that, i know this any game under 40 degrees i'm taking tom brady 10/10

 

[PremierDaTruth]

do they have the

same defenses, same coach, same coaching staff????

For arguments sake yes.

 

[Jplaya2023]

For arguments sake yes.

okay

0-40 degrees - tom brady 10/10
40-65 degrees clear skies - even
40-65 degrees slight rain - tom brady 6/10
40-65 degrees heavy rain - tom brady 7/10
66-80 degrees clear skies - Peyton Manning 6/10
66-80 degrees slight rain - even
66-80 degrees heavy rain (ala the bears SB) - Peyton manning 6/10
Dome - Peyton Manning 8-10

 

[nomoreneveragain]

Peyton Manning

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

It's any playoff game -

ALL i needed to read

 

[G.O.A.T]

okay

0-40 degrees - tom brady 10/10
40-65 degrees clear skies - even
40-65 degrees slight rain - tom brady 6/10
40-65 degrees heavy rain - tom brady 7/10
66-80 degrees clear skies - Peyton Manning 6/10
66-80 degrees slight rain - even
66-80 degrees heavy rain (ala the bears SB) - Peyton manning 6/10
Dome - Peyton Manning 8-10

So the difference between 40 degrees and 41 degrees would actually play an impact on who you choose as QB?

 

[LOUD]

ELIte Manning

 

[Jplaya2023]

So the difference between 40 degrees and 41 degrees would actually play an impact on who you choose as QB?

clear vs rainy day yeah it would. I still would go with Tom, but i'd give peyton more thought on a clear day more so than rainy

 

[unit321]

It's any playoff game with a random setting, could be a dome or 15 degrees with heavy snow.

No answer is wrong, this thread probably has been done before but maybe not this context. I'm curious to see the Colis overall stance on this. Who's your QB?!!?!?!?

I'm not touching that. Too many factors. Sunny and warm? Snowy and cold.
Heavy rain? Then, are the main running backs healthy or second string nobodys are filling in?
Playing in New England or Denver?

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

If this was years ago i`d say Brady, but he has been tarnished.

I`ll say Eli Manning

 

[Primetime21]

Hope we get to up this one last time in the playoffs

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

How many days in advance have the patriots had the opposing teams signals in this scenario