An eyewitness told The Buffalo News that the two men were attempting to collect a piece of driftwood lodged in an eddy near a point where people can easily enter the water.
“From the second he jumped in, it was obvious he was a really bad swimmer. He was smacking the water quickly and he was fatigued very fast. He swam only about 4 or 5 feet and came back to the rock so he could catch his breath.
"Everybody was saying, ‘Don’t go back in.' 'Take a breather.' 'Relax.' 'Take a piece of driftwood with you.’ The (man on shore) said, ‘Just let me go in.’ And (the other man) said, ‘I’m already wet. I’ll just try one more time.’
"He swam out, he still had the rope around his wrist. He was about 5 feet from the driftwood. The guy holding on to the rope just let it go, assuming he could go out and bring it back.”
“The current wasn’t that strong where they were. The guy (on shore) kept saying, ‘What’s the problem? The current isn’t that strong.’
“People kept telling the guy (on shore) that he needed to go in to save the guy who was going after the driftwood. He had one boot on, so he took off the boot and set his hat and his cellphone down and the second he got to (the man already in the water), the guy pushed him down.