Dude I been through
Bad Alex Smith
David Carr
Chris Weinke
Tim Rattay
JT O`Sullivan
Shaun Hill
Troy Smith
Trent Dilfer
Cody Pickett
Peyton is still a disappointing QB to me, he always will be. If Kaep is with the 49ers 15 years and in the playoffs 13/15 and only wins 1 SB, I`d consider him a disappointment too.
That's the sad thing about Manning, he has mastered the game so much and that's what's so sad, that he is so great but his play dips so much in the playoffs.
It's not just a team thing either, his QB rating drops about 10 points in the playoffs while other great QB's their rating rises.
