Scouting Report: Is Josh Rosen worth the #1 pick?

[feelosofer]

Rosen can sometimes hold the ball too long and invite sacks, but when his receivers played well enough against USC I did see him release the ball on time. He does seem lost when his reads aren't defined and he has to make a play. His play is mechanical which doesn't lend itself to much creativity outside the pocket. I see him as maybe a rich man's Eli Manning or something like Matt Ryan, whom in truth is more a top 15-10 QB than top 5. Good analysis. I would still take him #1 because Darnold has turnover & pressure issues.

I think this is why he's going to the Giants, they could keep the offense the same with him at the helm and Eli would be a good influence on him.

 

[godkiller]

I think this is why he's going to the Giants, they could keep the offense the same with him at the helm and Eli would be a good influence on him.

I think he goes to the Browns. The Browns would be foolish not to draft him. Browns should sign a FA QB just in case and if Rosen refuses to play, malign him in the media and trade him for picks.

 

[feelosofer]

I think he goes to the Browns. The Browns would be foolish not to draft him. Browns should sign a FA QB just in case and if Rosen refuses to play, malign him in the media and trade him for picks.

Probably though in all honesty I think they should trade back and commit to Kizer. If Rosen refuses to play for the Browns they might trade him to NY anyway like Manning/Rivers