Should Jade Cargill have gone to NXT before the main roster?

[2CT]

i seen the discussion at the end of the PLE thread so it's only right we do it the TSC way and put it to the vote

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

She didn’t need to be on NXT TV but she should have been down there training just as much as the NXT trainees are.

 

[curz]

AEW was her NXT, chick is either ready now or never gonna be. Despite however she looks, she’s a 32 yr old mother

 

[Rain]

No. You don't put a superstar down on NXT to satisfy basement dweller neckbeards.

 

[jadillac]

Maybe behind the scenes to train. But as a talent onscreen, absolutely not

 

[ALTRUISM]

I think she's doing alright on the main so far, but she's got the battery/spotlight placed on her so she's gotta be a 12/10 at all times to simply be accepted by certain fanbases

 

[thaKEAF]

if she was an a 8.5x11 this never would come up

 

[MenacingMonk]

 

[2CT]

She didn’t need to be on NXT TV but she should have been down there training just as much as the NXT trainees are.

so you saying the AEW 500+ day TBS title reign ain't train her enough?

 

[gdatruth]

she fine
if she didnt do AEW stunt and came straight off the street, NXT would've made sense

but she has trained and worked for the 2nd biggest wrestling promotion in the US
she has improved during her time and botch jumping in wasnt her fault (the ropes were loose). She'll probably never be able to put on 5 star matches but weaknesses can be hidden with the right opponents & booking.

not sure what her schedule is like but it would be best if she worked as many house shows/non televised matches as possible some of the vet women to get more live ring time off tv

 

[MenacingMonk]

She just needs to work on her timing and communication. Those are the things I noticed in the E matches I saw. She looked lost at moments. It’s weird because I never noticed her lost during her AEW run. Her timing was still an issue, but she never looked lost.

 

[TL15]

She’s got MAYBE 10 years in the business left (that’s generous) and can have viable feuds with Bianca, Charlotte, Becky, Bayley, Naomi, Banks (if she returns), Nyla, etc. all of those are money without having to be technical wrestling classics.

We don’t need to see her develop chain wrestling against Wendy Choo

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

Maybe behind the scenes to train. But as a talent onscreen, absolutely not

Exactly.

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

so you saying the AEW 500+ day TBS title reign ain't train her enough?

She wrestled like once a week if that and mostly squashes or against jobbers. I know she trained behind the scenes with Danielson and whoever else was there as coaches, but she wasn’t getting the quantity of training she needed.

As I’ve said before, unless someone is just a natural, AEW isn’t the place to go if you’re a green talent, especially if you don’t want to work the indies to get reps in.

 

[2CT]

some valid answers

see what happens when you make a new thread instead of just posting in giant ass megathreads