I only watched this just today, but I'm surprised at how little talk Chess' first is getting. I thought he was on his game in the first. The rest of the battle wasn't on that level for either dude.
Reed did better (not hard to do), but I wasn't exactly enthralled by his showing. His second was pretty ok, first and third I have minimal memory of (I'll rewatch in case).
Overall Grade: B-. Chess gets a B/B+, Reed gets a B/B-; and the battle as a whole was just ok. I'd edge it to Chess, but can't diss people who preferred Reed.
Random: Nobody noticed that Chess looked like he actually had a headache this whole battle? He wasn't screaming with his whole body like usual and he was rubbing his temples throughout the entire joint.