So according to Coli logic...Marino was a bum

[JLova]

0 Super Bowls = bum.

Bradshaw > Eli > Dilfer> Marino

Aikman > Montana

Flacco > McNabb

 

[Codeine Bryant]

Adam Morrison = LeBron James

 

[Heelmatic]

Idk if thats necessarily Coli logic or if thats most of the talking head's logic out there.

How would that logic = Aikman > Montana though? Montana has more SB rings and SB MVP's.

 

[Duvali]

you know you are smarter than this. what matters is the role of the quarterback at the time of the win. was the quarterback a playmaker, game manager or was he asked to simply hand the ball off?

 

[Akata Man Bromo]

Stat padder

 

[eastside313]

Marino is the all time interception leader

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Do we really need to go down this path, really?

 

[JLova]

Idk if thats necessarily Coli logic or if thats most of the talking head's logic out there.

How would that logic = Aikman > Montana though? Montana has more SB rings and SB MVP's.

I just threw that in there for no reason....

 

[JLova]

you know you are smarter than this. what matters is the role of the quarterback at the time of the win. was the quarterback a playmaker, game manager or was he asked to simply hand the ball off?

Absolutely.

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

Flacco > McNabb

This is actually true though

 

[JLova]

This is actually true though

 

[yseJ]

you know well no one says "Bradshaw > Eli > Dilfer> Marino"

rings only come to play if players you are comparing are comparable overall

for example, emmitt has more rings than barry but no one puts him over barry...cuz they werent close.

but something like TO vs Moss...their careers are pretty damn close, if one of them had a ring it could play a factor in their comparison.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

This is actually true though

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

you know well no one says "Bradshaw > Eli > Dilfer> Marino"

rings only come to play if players you are comparing are comparable overall

for example, emmitt has more rings than barry but no one puts him over barry...cuz they werent close.

but something like TO vs Moss...their careers are pretty damn close, if one of them had a ring it could play a factor in their comparison.

Aint no comparison to me.....Moss>TO

 

[Born2BKing]

Marino is the all time interception leader

Pretty sure that's