The best starting pitcher between these 3 players??

[The Entity]

still Greg Mad dog Maddux

18 gold gloves. many great players don't even play 18 seasons

lol at this

 

[HHR]

Maddux was a great fielder....but there is almost zero chance he deserved all 18 of those Gold Gloves. The award is almost entirely reputation based and has pretty slim correlation to actual ability. Once he had won 4-5 in a row, he was essentially guaranteed the award until he stopped playing

See: Derek Jeter's FIVE awards..

...and of course, my favorite Gold Glove anecdote ever, Rafael Palmeiro won the 1999 Gold Glove despite playing only 246 innings in the field (across 28 games). He made 128 starts at DESIGNATED HITTER.

So yeah, Maddux >>>> , but GGs are stupid.

 

[King Karim]

lol at this

what was funny about it?

 

[Doctor Wily]

Randy was dominant at his peak more than maddux or Pedro was

At least against Pedro or Maddux there was a chance to at least put up a good at bat.

 

[Da_Eggman]

Randy would be the guy I'd want if it was a game 7

 

[mastermind]

Pedro