Top 25 worst NFL coaching hires this century: From Bobby Petrino to Nick Saban to Urban Meyer and more

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
26,522
Reputation
2,441
Daps
63,914
Reppin
NYC

here are the bottom 5

5. Nathaniel Hackett (Broncos)​

Record: 4-11

Hackett is a beloved companion and former colleague of Aaron Rodgers, who's gone to bat for him at multiple spots. But Hackett's team-up with former Seahawks star Russell Wilson went about as poorly as it could've, with clock-management issues repeatedly dooming Denver before a 51-14 Christmas Day defeat all but sealed his exit. His December dismissal made him just the fifth coach since the AFL-NFL merger to not finish his first season.

team logo

4. Josh McDaniels (Broncos)​

Record: 11-17

A hotshot hire from Bill Belichick's coaching tree, McDaniels didn't make it to his first game before dealing quarterback Jay Cutlerover offseason miscommunications, and he didn't make it through Year 2 after an NFL investigation found his staff had videotaped an opponent's walkthrough practice during the season. Somehow he returned to a head gig with the rival Raiders in 2022, only to once again be dismissed halfway through his second season.

team logo

3. Cam Cameron (Dolphins)​

Record: 1-15

This is what you get when Nick Saban abruptly resigns from atop the staff. Cameron oversaw some electric offenses with the San Diego Chargers, but his first and last head coaching opportunity at the NFL level brought Miami its worst finish in four decades. Shuffling between an aging Trent Green and backups Cleo Lemon and John Beck under center, Cameron's one-year stop was made more unsettling by the fact Miami passed over future Steelers icon Mike Tomlin to hire him.

team logo

2. Bobby Petrino (Falcons)​

Record: 3-10

There's no doubt Petrino found himself in an unexpectedly dire situation when Michael Vick, the team's emergent star quarterback, went to prison for dogfighting prior to the 2007 season, leaving Atlanta without answers under center. But Petrino's response was even more unexpected: He resigned from his post after just 13 games, informing the Falcons of his decision via notes left in the locker room. Before the dust could even settle, Petrino was back in the college ranks as the head coach of Arkansas, his name etched into Falcons history solely for his sprint out of town.

team logo

1. Urban Meyer (Jaguars)​

Record: 2-11

Desperate for rejuvenation, the Jaguars looked past Meyer's history of fielding troubled talents at Florida and Ohio State, instead focusing on his three national championships. It took but a few months for the trouble to follow Meyer to the NFL. Despite inheriting No. 1 overall pick Trevor Lawrence, he made it just 13 games before ownership pulled the plug. The worst part wasn't the losses but the scandals sandwiched between them, none greater than a seemingly flirtatious trip to the bar -- captured in viral video -- while the rest of the team flew home from a defeat.
 

Treblemaka

President, BYNKRadio.com (Retired)
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
7,398
Reputation
4,424
Daps
60,588
Reppin
Black Empowerment
I love seeing college coaches at the NFL level. I get to find out who's a tyrant a$$hole and who can actually coach.

Its different leading men who make more than you who have the power to get you fired.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
45,993
Reputation
2,772
Daps
67,403
Reppin
The Yay
I wanted Jim Tomsula to succeed and he was a likeable meathead position coach.... but it was clear from like the first two games he was in over his head as a head coach. The Niners roster was kinda shytty too at that point.
 

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
26,522
Reputation
2,441
Daps
63,914
Reppin
NYC
Where's Matt Patricia?

9. Matt Patricia (Lions)​

Record: 13-29-1

Another wizard under Bill Belichick who struggled mightily to replicate the Patriots aura elsewhere, Patricia inherited a reasonably competitive Lions roster from under the watch of Jim Caldwell, only to oversee a perceived breakdown in the very culture of the organization, with big-name veterans like future Super Bowl champion Darius Slay clashing with his personality.
 
Top