What RB would you rather have? Gibbs or James Cook

[Alvin]

 

[AceDeuceTrey]

Is this a serious question OP???

 

[Bboystyle]

 

[Maliciouslarynx]

 

[CHICAGO]

TRICK QUESTION?



​

 

[Bigwhite2498]

Cooks is good but Gibbs is like the 4th best back in the league

 

[feelosofer]

Um Jameer Gibbs is a too 5 RB in the league. Cook is good but I don't think he is the game breaker Gibbs is.

 

[CM_Burns]

As a Lions fan, Gibbs is a little overrated by people who don't watch the Lions much. He's more than a step below Saquon/Henry. But he's still very good and I'd take him over Cook

 

[Alvin]

Is this a serious question OP???

Cook part of the reason why the Bills were good, dude was dominating they run game which would set Josh up for those TD rushes he did. He was used imo similarly to how the Lions used Gibbs, Lions just have better receivers and goff is the old statue type of QB. idk why dudes are acting like Cook is a scrub.

 

[Alvin]

As a Lions fan, Gibbs is a little overrated by people who don't watch the Lions much. He's more than a step below Saquon/Henry. But he's still very good and I'd take him over Cook

Henry, Saquon and Josh Jacobs, 1, 2 and 3 for top backs, CMC is there too but gets injured a lot.

 

[CM_Burns]

Henry, Saquon and Josh Jacobs, 1, 2 and 3 for top backs, CMC is there too but gets injured a lot.

CMC was everyone's #1 last yr over Saquon and Henry, who knows going forward. He might be done. This year is proof that the team situation matters a lot. Somebody like Nick Chubb could get traded and put up 1500 next year

 

[Alvin]

CMC was everyone's #1 last yr over Saquon and Henry, who knows going forward. He might be done. This year is proof that the team situation matters a lot. Somebody like Nick Chubb could get traded and put up 1500 next year

I was going to say, Giants didn't know how to use Barkley and Titans are ASS without Henry and became one trick ponies. Chubb was great too, but also could rely on Kareem Hunt, Hunt gone and Chubb had that knee injury and his oline can't stop a cold or create space.

 

[Primetime21]

I lean Gibbs because he’s more explosive but Cook was criminally underutilized by the Bills

 

[Piff Perkins]

As a Lions fan, Gibbs is a little overrated by people who don't watch the Lions much. He's more than a step below Saquon/Henry. But he's still very good and I'd take him over Cook

My brother in Christ, Gibbs is at least RB3 in the league. Only behind Saquon and Henry.

 

[Bigwhite2498]

My brother in Christ, Gibbs is at least RB3 in the league. Only behind Saquon and Henry.

He not above Bijan