What would it take for either a punter or kicker win MVP? *edit 1982 a kicker won it

[Cladyclad]

 

[Padron1926]

If he also played quarterback

 

[Canada Goose]

Adam Vinatieri could won them for those superbowl games he played with NE...

 

[Brozay]

No, never again. Cant believe that shyt ever happened, thats just

 

[BaggerofTea]

An elite defense on par with the 85 bears while your kicker can hit 70yd field goals and throw fake field goal strikes 1 or twice a game

 

[Cladyclad]

What if a kicker is godly kicking 60 & 70 yd fg's like they 30yds?



15-16 from 60
25-25 from 50
21-21 40 & under
61-62
3 60yd game winners
And three highlight tackles
4 kick returns allowed all season

Is that enough to be considered mvp?

 

[Brozay]

An elite defense on par with the 85 bears while your kicker can hit 70yd field goals and throw fake field goal strikes 1 or twice a game

I have wondered why there hasnt been 1 outlier of a kicker to come around booting 75 yarders like they werent shyt

I wouldnt be shocked to see one in the next 20 years, it has to come eventually

 

[Omar Little]

Nothing.That will never happen.Maybe a super bowl if they haven't done that already.

 

[Ice Cold]

Never undreamt circumstances would a punter ever be mvp. Has a kicker ever been super bowl mvp?

 

[smitty22]

hgh

 

[Cladyclad]

Never undreamt circumstances would a punter ever be mvp. Has a kicker ever been super bowl mvp?

What if he pin other teams inside the 10 like 85-90%

With 4 forced fumbles
3 recovered

 

[the cac mamba]

if he won like half the games in the season as the clock ran out

 

[Reid2Achieve]

If he is a beast at other positions besides kicker, on some do it all shyt.

 

[Bboystyle]

dude would have to kick 65+ FG's all season long, make 100% onside kicks, and kick every kickoff into the stands just to be considered an MVP candidate.

Punters need to pin the ball inside the one yard line on every punt no matter where they are at but they still wont get that MVP

 

[The Devil's Advocate]

i've often thought about this... like if i could be the best of all time at any position... it'd easily be kicker.. and i'd get qb money


imagine if you were a lock to make a FG anywhere on the field... team wouldn't even need a punter... we could be on the 1 and i could boot a 115 yard kick







yea.... that's the ONLY way... cause even if your D is amazing and you win every game including the SB 6-0.... they still will find someone on the defense to give it to