Who are you taking? Mike Evans or Devante Adams?

[BucciMane]

Yeah. Davante was that dude for a few years. At his zenith he was definitely better than Evans in any year.

Adams did have Rodgers as his QB, but he also had THREE first-team all-pro selections. That shows you are elite and viewed as a top two WR at WORST in the NFL in terms of production. Mike Evans has never done that.

If someone wants to say Evans had a better career so far, sure, I'll listen. However, I view players with strong peaks and primes more than players that are just consistently very good. I guess you can say Evans has been "very very good", but I have never viewed him as truly elite.

 

[Mirin4rmfar]

Am I taking an elite all-pro in their prime or the Frank Gore of WR's? .

Anyone saying Evans is out of their damn minds if you're talking about who has been the better player during their peak/prime..

lol come on now, Evans has spent years with absolute garbage at QB..he still put up numbers.

 

[broller]

Adams did have Rodgers as his QB, but he also had THREE first-team all-pro selections. That shows you are elite and viewed as a top two WR at WORST in the NFL in terms of production. Mike Evans has never done that.

If someone wants to say Evans had a better career so far, sure, I'll listen. However, I view players with strong peaks and primes more than players that are just consistently very good. I guess you can say Evans has been "very very good", but I have never viewed him as truly elite.

All-Pro for WR is now 3 players on the first team , but it's still an impressive feat. Adams was also first team All-Pro in 2022 when he was a Raider.

 

[broller]

lol come on now, Evans has spent years with absolute garbage at QB..he still put up numbers.

He hasn't had garbage QBs for the most part. He's had Jameis, Tom, and Baker. Jameis has often been a guy who can put up bulk numbers. He just turns it over. Tom is Tom and Baker has been good in Tampa.

In year 1, Evans had Josh McCown IIRC

 

[RhodyRum]

Devante Adams always has a look on his face as if he's legit worried if whether or not he unplugged his iron or left a stove burner on when he left the crib that morning.