Who is better Peyton or Eli?

[twan83]

Was talking to family about this and its a good legit question cuz most dont even know who they would pick cant go wrong with either though

peyton will pick you apart

eli is clutch as hell


Me personally rather go with peyton

 

[Typical Knicks Fan]

Eli. Close Thread.

 

[Carl Spackler]

2 > 1

 

[JYoung24]

is this a joke peyton easily

 

[Dirk Diggler]

Even though the Giants are my team I feel Peyton is more experienced under pressure than Eli is.

 

[Shameonyou]

worst thread ever

 

[DallasTxRep]

Eli doesn't even play in a Bowl without those Defenses. Peyton carried those good Colts teams
Don't get me wrong Eli is cold....as much as I hate to say it

Hypothetical....
Would the Colts have won that Bowl with Eli as the QB?
We know the the answer to, if Peyton was on the Giants

 

[Street Knowledge]

Peyton Regular season, Eli in the clutch and In the Postseason

Overall Peyton is ranked higher

 

[Youhadasparkwhenustarted]

Eli doesn't even play in a Bowl without those Defenses. Peyton carried those good Colts teams
Don't get me wrong Eli is cold....as much as I hate to say it

Hypothetical....
Would the Colts have won that Bowl with Eli as the QB?
We know the the answer to, if Peyton was on the Giants

The Giants don't necessarily win with Peyton as their quarterback either. This is a question I would answer when Eli is near the back end of his career, you can't judge bodies of work when one player still has alot more football in him.

 

[Wiirdo]

Peyton is just a much better player. This is obvious.

fukk a ring argument. fakkits.

 

[Ohms Law]

Never thought id see the day when this would become a plausible question.

 

[Street Knowledge]

Eli 2011 Playoffs*
1219 Yrds/65%/9 TDs/1 pick/7.5 YPA/ 103.3 passer rating*

Peyton in his only Super Bowl run in 2007*

63.4% for 1,034 yards, 6.8 YPA, 3 TD, 7 INT, 70.5 passer rating(lowest for a SB winning QB)*

 

[Dat916nigga]

Eli 2011 Playoffs*
1219 Yrds/65%/9 TDs/1 pick/7.5 YPA/ 103.3 passer rating*

Peyton in his only Super Bowl run in 2007*

63.4% for 1,034 yards, 6.8 YPA, 3 TD, 7 INT, 70.5 passer rating(lowest for a SB winning QB)*

peyton was the heart and soul of the colts for a long time but you just can't say that he carried the colts during that SB run

obviously peyton's had the better career of the two but from this point forward give me eli

 

[Joe Sixpack]

Are you nikkas like 10??

What's with all the elementary, abcd, 123 dumb ass threads??

 

[23Barrettcity]

Eli doesn't even play in a Bowl without those Defenses. Peyton carried those good Colts teams
Don't get me wrong Eli is cold....as much as I hate to say it

Hypothetical....
Would the Colts have won that Bowl with Eli as the QB?
We know the the answer to, if Peyton was on the Giants

You. Can't say that cause without Eli we don't make the Super Bowl either it's a combo . He played great in both the runs