Who Would You Start Your Team With, Carmelo Or Cp3?

[FiveShoTz]

To me Both Top 10 Players


But i would take Melo

Cp3 isnt the scorer melo is

And cp3 has never even advanced past the 2nd round



Who would you take

 

[Primetime21]

Cp3 isnt the scorer melo is

And cp3 has never even advanced past the 2nd round

When you look at the entire bend of their playoff careers Carmelo been knocked out the first round what, 9 out of 10 times, 8 out of 9?

Your ceiling is probably the same with either of these guys as your best player but I'd pick CP3

 

[Illuminatos]

When you look at the entire bend of their playoff careers Carmelo been knocked out the first round what, 9 out of 10 times, 8 out of 9?

Your ceiling is probably the same with either of these guys as your best player but I'd probably pick CP3

But Melo has went farther in the playoffs than CP3 though.

 

[Primetime21]

But Melo has went farther in the playoffs than CP3 though.

I think we've established that

 

[Stinky Diver]

CP3 before or after his knee injuries? Because if we're talking before, this shyt isn't even a question.

 

[FS4LFE]

You're not winning a chip with a PG as your best player so Melo.

 

[Silkk]

Chris

 

[Silkk]

You're not winning a chip with a PG as your best player so Melo.

Magic Johnson, Isiah Thomas, Chauncey Billups

 

[FreshFromATL]

Neither will ever win a ring (at least while playing for their current teams)...

 

[FS4LFE]

Magic Johnson, Isiah Thomas, Chauncey Billups

25-30 years ago. And Billups was a rare exception. I'm referring to the modern day NBA.

 

[Silkk]

25-30 years ago. And Billups was a rare exception. I'm referring to the modern day NBA.

Tony Parker

 

[Shadow King]

Melo.

I wouldn't try to build a chip-caliber squad around a PG unless they're big (not necessarily 6'9" but i.e. Magic) or athletic enough to expand their production into guarding SG's, grabbing their own boards to lead the break or taking over themselves (Westbrook, healthy Rose)

 

[FTBS]

at one outlier trip to the CF proving to be the difference. They have the same number of playoff series wins. Chris has more trips beyond the first round despite being in the league 2 fewer years and playing in the West his whole career but fukk all that fact and logic...this question is easy. CP3 is a loser and a choker who has never done anything in his career. While Melo is a clutch pure scoring monster, with one scoring title, who's teammates are to blame for everything except that solitary, never been approached again, trip to the CF. In all seriousness it's a toss up and it really shouldn't be.

 

[ScottyG]

Melo and it shouldn't a question. If Paul couldn't win with that Hornets squad or this clippers squad, he has no chance ever

 

[The War Report]

at one outlier trip to the CF proving to be the difference. They have the same number of playoff series wins. Chris has more trips beyond the first round despite being in the league 2 fewer years and playing in the West his whole career but fukk all that fact and logic...this question is easy. CP3 is a loser and a choker who has never done anything in his career. While Melo is a clutch pure scoring monster, with one scoring title, who's teammates are to blame for everything except that solitary, never been approached again, trip to the CF. In all seriousness it's a toss up and it really shouldn't be.

If you're strictly talking about winning championships, then really no one has accomplished shyt in their careers.