Who'd fare better? an NFL QB & high school WR's *vs* a high school QB & NFL WR's?

[jadillac]

Pro-bowl NFL QB throwing to 4-5-star high school WR's vs 4-5 star high school QB throwing to pro-bowl WR's

Who'd fare better against the WORST ranked NFL defense and why?

 

[BlueHeffner]

NFL QB to HS receivers hands down

A Hs Qb to NFL Receivers would be

 

[onelastdeath]

Pro QB to Amateur WRs. Speed and Separation can be done by those WRs.

 

[Tony D'Amato]

What kinda dumb azz question is this.

With all do respect

 

[BreezyH]

pro qb with hs wr's. no hs qb is poised enough to stand in there

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

Pro QB obviously.

 

[PortCityProphet]

Ain't no hs wr beating a jam by a pro cb they ain't strong enough to deal with the physicality. In situations like this always go with the one that has the least amount physical attributes are needed and that'd be qb. Gimme the hs qb throwing to pros

 

[#1 pick]

Ain't no hs wr beating a jam by a pro cb they ain't strong enough to deal with the physicality. In situations like this always go with the one that has the least amount physical attributes are needed and that'd be qb. Gimme the hs qb throwing to pros

While this is generally true, I'll take Calvin Johnson out of Sandy Springs and Randy Moss out of Rand with prime Peyton for 100 Alex. Give me A.J. Green and Julio out of HS as well.

 

[TheGreatShowtime]

Treon Harris was a 4-star high school QB recruit. I'll take the NFL QB with high school WRs

 

[jadillac]

Treon Harris was a 4-star high school QB recruit. I'll take the NFL QB with high school WRs

how Sway, how?

 

[jadillac]

What kinda dumb azz question is this.

With all do respect

answer the damn question....or

 

[resurrection]

I'll take the NFL QB hands down, but both are getting absolutely destroyed with no vaseline so it's kinda a moot point

 

[distinguishedNOW]

You saw how the Cardinals fell off the map once Ryan Lindley became starter, and he was a halfway decent college QB. Obviously it starts with the QB.

edit- This was a pretty terrible hypothetical question tbh.

 

[HarlemUSA]

Cassel was able to play in the nfl without taking a snap in college and go 10-6 with Mauce and Welker


But then those Arizona qbs last year

 

[PortCityProphet]

While this is generally true, I'll take Calvin Johnson out of Sandy Springs and Randy Moss out of Rand with prime Peyton for 100 Alex. Give me A.J. Green and Julio out of HS as well.

They ain't doing nothing against pro DBs. They were 17-18 beating dudes who were 5'8 175 lbs. Let a pro cb put hands on them they not going anywhere. That strength difference is a huge factor and pros can run with them too.