Who's the better qb... Vick vs romo

[john goodman]

Who you got

 

[mrken12]

Vick. It's not even close. He at least can win playoff games.

 

[Reggie]

Vick is better slightly but they are close. Romo gets shytted on the regular for only having one playoff win but people act like he isn't an undrafted free agent who is a success story for even being in the league and starting. While Vick was the first pick in the draft and I think he has all of two playoff wins and has been living off that reputation he earned after he beat Green Bay back in his second year. But overall he has been a disappointment and that's not even including the dogfighting stuff.

 

[Chris.B]

Romo

Vick cannot make it through a 16 week season without breaking something

 

[feelosofer]

Romo and it's not that close. All that supposed 'choking' is flim flam. Even without elite weapons Romo will give you 4000 yds.

 

[Bone$]

If vick has continuously blew it on the big stage, year after year.. Man listen

 

[intruder]

If he's even 80% healthy: Vick.

But Romo is not as bad as some people make him seem to be

 

[Master Teacher]

Romo

Vick cannot make it through a 16 week season without breaking something

Whats the point of making through a 16 week season when you never in the playoffs

 

[FcKuPaYmE]

Vick the Gawd!!

 

[Absolut]

Whats the point of making through a 16 week season when you never in the playoffs

not sure what postseason appearances have to do with said topic at hand, but both have made the playoffs as a starter an equal number of times (3), in the same number of seasons as starters (7)

 

[Ashyneezz]

Romo

 

[Jax]

Vick in the pocket>Romo
Vick healthy and running>Everyone in the league.

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

If vick has continuously blew it on the big stage, year after year.. Man listen

What has Vick done beside win in Lambeau a decade ago?

Hes been a inaacurate turnover prone player mixed in with a few good years,judging by this site youd think hes some sort of legendary hof player

 

[HHR]

Whats the point of making through a 16 week season when you never in the playoffs

Romo has started the majority of his team's games in 6 seasons and has been to the postseason 3 times.
Vick has started the majority of his team's games in 7 seasons and has been to the postseason 3 times.

......................................

 

[Absolut]

Romo has started the majority of his team's games in 6 seasons and has been to the postseason 3 times.
Vick has started the majority of his team's games in 7 seasons and has been to the postseason 3 times.

......................................

exactly. i even gave vick the benefit of including romos season with 6 games played while excluding vicks season of 4 games played. since they were 1-5 in those 6 games played its not like he put them in good position for the postseason though