Whose career is honestly the most disappointing- CP3, D12 OR Melo?

[daboywonder2002]

Howard at least carried a team to the finals and won a few DPOY awards but I don't know if it's the baby mamas or maybe he just doesn't love the game.

Paul- never been passed the second round. Other point guards have come in and pushed Paul out of the top 5 pgs.

Melo- complete failure. Had 1 great year and that was with Billups. Scoring and Olympic titles but not much nba success. Loyalty to the Knicks will probably be his downfall

 

[NoMorePie]

Howard at least made it to the finals

Melo at least has like 4 (is it 4?) Olympic gold medals and scoring titles (since you said career...)

Chris Paul, um...

 

[Colin X]

Melo and D12 have accomplished more than CP3 how is this even a question

 

[Remote]

Probably Chris Paul.

Melo had maybe 1 real chance with a decent team in Denver in a tough conference. The reality is he never had the type of help or good coaches that other players have had.
Dwight was probably never the same after he left Orlando.

 

[Tide Run This]

Cliff Paul

 

[CHICAGO]

BACK INJURY ENDED D12s PRIME PREMATURELY.

CP3 AND MELO ARE JUST LOSERS.



​

 

[Rigby.]

CP3 is by far the biggest loser out those 3 but Carmelo had no debilitating injuries to his game, so one is left to wonder why he couldnt have been the first to win out this list. Dwight probably had the most dominant peak out of those 3 and the shortest, so I'd say he achieved quite a bit in that time.

 

[e001]

CP3, I don't think it's even close. Melo at least made his choice and Dwight is somewhat successful

 

[Alexander The Great]

all 3 have had great careers and will end up in the Hall of fame

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Melo had the Knicks on the come up, people forget that 54 win season. Not his fault everything went to complete shyt around him afterwards

 

[GzUp]

Howard shouldn't be in the list

 

[CodeBlaMeVi]

I would say Melo. Just seems like the most complete player and all went to waste. Not completely his fault.

 

[Damnshow]

depends on how you look at it, if strictly team success then its chris paul

but chris paul is still a great player up to this day, dwight and melo already fell off the map

dwight went to finals in 2009 and conference finals in 2010, so you can say he did the most in his prime. But it still feels he could have done more, I remember celtics were like 3-0 in 2010, and if they had KG in 09 then dwight would have never made it to finals. Dwight's career should have been better as he had no competition in his position back in late 00s and early 10s

 

[ikbm]

 

[CHICAGO]

THIS STUPID CONSIDERING PAUL
DIDNT ENTER THE LEAGUE UNTIL 2005-06.





​