Why Is Eminem considered a Goat when most black artists have better catalogues than him?

[blackslash]

This blows my mind

Let's just get this out of the way
If em in your top 5 you are most likely a self hating c00n or a white boy

Now tell me why this dude considered a Goat when black artists such as, t.i, the game, Rick ross, cole, drake, ludacris, wayne,
Sht the list goes on and on
So wats up with this narrative of him being a Goat

 

[ManBearPig]

Cole having a better catalog then Eminem


Those nikkaz you mentioned are nowhere as nice.

 

[big bun]

Marshall been trash for more than 10 years, but the list you put him up against is

 

[California Burrito]

not one of those artist you named have a "MMLP" or even close to it

ludacris

 

[Prominence0]

Eminem being a better lyricist is the reason. Half of the garbage he put out on those albums was for shock value.

And I admit most was garbage and he knew it.

But when he was on mixtapes and released underground leaks, the shyt he said was mind blowing.

Listen to those Green Lantern mixtapes.

Eminem got skills my nikka.

 

[flea]

Cacs claim he's the GOAT. Oh and @SunZoo

 

[blackestofpanthers]

not one of those artist you named have a "MMLP" or even close to it

ludacris

The carter 1 and 2>>>>>>>mmlp
Trap muzik and urban legend>>>>>>mmlp

 

[Luck]

I never met anyone in real life that called eminem the goat, even listens to dude or has ever listened to dude like that.

This is some internet / cac shyt.

 

[Prominence0]

I never met anyone in real life that called eminem the goat, even listens to dude or has ever listened to dude like that.

This is some internet / cac shyt.

 

[blackslash]

not one of those artist you named have a "MMLP" or even close to it


ludacris

Chicken n beer better than any album em put out

 

[blackslash]

It is

Ur a cac if u even consider em a Goat

Period

 

[OG Talk]

This blows my mind

Let's just get this out of the way
If em in your top 5 you are most likely a self hating c00n or a white boy

Now tell me why this dude considered a Goat when black artists such as, t.i, the game, Rick ross, cole, drake, ludacris, wayne,
Sht the list goes on and on
So wats up with this narrative of him being a Goat

The same reason most people consider Jay-Z better than Nas or Drake better than Kendrick..

When you go with the "numbers don't lie" theory or get into the popularity over substance game, you gotta ride that sh1t till the wheels fall off...

Respect the game, YALL the ones that made the rules

 

[Da King]

Who considers him the GOAT besides cacs and c00ns (like :fif?

 

[mrken12]

Wayne is nowhere close to being in the GOAT conversation. Drake?

But I agree that Eminem's catalog is for the most part.

I've said numerous times how Encore was one of the WOAT rap albums of all time.

And none of his albums have aged well. The only other person in music who was overrated so much for mediocrity was Elvis.

 

[OnlyInCalifornia]

Good question.

His discography is weak IMO. He has 3 good albums out of what is it, 7-8 now? So more than half his music is trash.